Re: Last Call Comments on Web Storage

2011-11-18 Thread Arthur Barstow
Ashok - your comment has been added to the comment tracking document for this LC: http://www.w3.org/2008/webapps/wiki/WebStorage-Comments-LC-25Oct2011#LC-1 If you want to propose extensions or changes to Web Storage, please use [Bugzilla] and please feel free to contribute to the group's

Re: Last Call Comments on Web Storage

2011-11-14 Thread Arthur Barstow
Hi Ashok, I agree with Tab's comments and wanted to mention some of the related history ... The relationships between WebApps' various database related specs has been discussed before and [DB-wiki] was created to help clarify the relationships. The good news is there are now 2 specs rather

Re: Last Call Comments on Web Storage

2011-11-14 Thread Yehuda Katz
I don't think it's controversial amongst practitioners that both Web Storage and IndexedDB are useful and should exist. WebStorage is a very simple key-value store that is useful for very common, simple cases, while IndexedDB is a full-on database solution more appropriate for complex cases. One

Last Call Comments on Web Storage

2011-11-11 Thread ashok malhotra
DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed below are mine and may not reflect the opinions of my employer or the W3C TAG Comments: o One use of local storage might be to store personal preferences, such as travel preferences or personal information such as medical history. In such cases, you may

Re: Last Call Comments on Web Storage

2011-11-11 Thread Charles Pritchard
On 11/11/2011 12:24 PM, Tab Atkins Jr. wrote: On Fri, Nov 11, 2011 at 11:54 AM, ashok malhotra ashok.malho...@oracle.com wrote: o One use of local storage might be to store personal preferences, such as travel preferences or personal information such as medical history. In such cases, you may