[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 0

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
Hi Marcos, All, I have prepared comments to the PC. I will send them in chunks for easier reference just in case they need some discussions. The mails will be without introductions. The review process is not yet completed, though. Thanks. Kind regards, Marcin

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 3

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
EDITORIALs 8.3 Some general rule for how attributes are to be processed a user agent or conformance checker are also ... should be Some general rule for how attributes are to be processed by a user agent or a conformance checker are also ... ... given the processing rules that type of

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, interoperability

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
8.2 For the sake of interoperability, extensions to the configuration document are NOT RECOMMENDED. 8.3 User agents SHOULD impose their own implementation-specific limits on the values of otherwise unconstrained attribute types, e.g. to prevent denial of service attacks, to guard against

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 1

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
EDITORIALs and Global stuff Unify inform an vs. inform the throughout the full document. Unify i.e. (i.e.,) and e.g. (e.g.,) to follow fully either American- or British-English. Should not the RFC2119 terms in authoring guidelines be also in uppercase? What is the normative status of the

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 4

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
8.12 in which case a user agents that should be in which case a user agent that In other words, the required attribute denotes that a feature is absolutely needed by the widget to function correctly, and without the availability of this feature the widget serves no useful purpose or won't

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 2

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
EDITORIALs 6.5 via a content elements src attribute. should be via a content element's src attribute. A default start file must appear at either the ... A default start file is not an anchor. 6.6 Authoring guideline If using [SVG] as an icon format and one intends it to be animated, use

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, zip-rel-path ABNF

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
Error in ABNF: localized-folder vs. locale-folder Error with ABNF utf8-chars = safe-chars / U+0080 and beyond and beyond does not fit here Section 2. of RFC2279 shows that all UTF-8 characters above U+0080 are encoded with byte values over 0x80. So utf-8 production equals to cp437

[widgets] PC Last Call comments, 5

2009-05-31 Thread Marcin Hanclik
5.3 encoding indicator should be Language encoding flag (EFS) to match http://www.pkware.com/documents/casestudies/APPNOTE.TXT Access Systems Germany GmbH Essener Strasse 5 | D-46047 Oberhausen HRB 13548 Amtsgericht Duisburg Geschaeftsfuehrer: Michel

Re: [WebIDL] module in ECMAScript

2009-05-31 Thread Cameron McCormack
Hi Marcin. Marcin Hanclik: In BONDI WebIDL we implicitly assumed that module definition is mapped to the interface naming. Thus bondi.filesystem.* is available without explicit creation of the filesystem property of the bondi object. This implicit creation of property may result from the