Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-23 Thread Nicholas Jacobson
Oops, you're right. What I should have said is to use a blank docstring as follows: Function docstring. def foo: ... or: Module docstring. def foo: ... --- Anthony Baxter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Monday 21 March 2005 20:08, Nicholas Jacobson wrote: How do you distinguish

Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-23 Thread Anthony Baxter
On Tuesday 22 March 2005 05:58, Nicholas Jacobson wrote: Oops, you're right. What I should have said is to use a blank docstring as follows: It's still unclear to me what a file containing a single docstring followed by a def() line means. And this ambiguity doesn't seem to be solvable, so

Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-21 Thread Nicholas Jacobson
Rule #1: If the docstring is the first line of a module, it's the module's docstring. Rule #2: If the docstring comes right before a class/function, it's that class/function's docstring. How do you distinguish between a docstring at the top of a module that's immediately followed by a

Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-21 Thread Anthony Baxter
On Monday 21 March 2005 20:08, Nicholas Jacobson wrote: How do you distinguish between a docstring at the top of a module that's immediately followed by a function? Is it the module docstring or the function docstring? It's both. The docstring would be assigned to both the module

Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-21 Thread Brett C.
Nicholas Jacobson wrote: IIRC, Guido once mentioned that he regretted not setting function docstrings to come before the function declaration line, instead of after. He did, but I don't know how strong that regret is. i.e. This describes class Bar. class Bar: ... Or with a decorator: This

Fwd: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-21 Thread Eric Nieuwland
Nicholas Jacobson wrote: IIRC, Guido once mentioned that he regretted not setting function docstrings to come before the function declaration line, instead of after. [ examples deleted ] I think that commenting the function before its declaration, at the same tabbed point, increases the code's

Re: [Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-21 Thread Greg Ewing
Nicholas Jacobson wrote: If a programmer wanted a docstring for the function but not the module, a blank first line would do the trick. A docstring for the module but not the function? Put a blank line between the module's docstring and the function. -1 on all this making of blank lines

[Python-Dev] docstring before function declaration

2005-03-20 Thread Nicholas Jacobson
IIRC, Guido once mentioned that he regretted not setting function docstrings to come before the function declaration line, instead of after. i.e. This describes class Bar. class Bar: ... Or with a decorator: This describes class Bar. @classmethod class Bar: ... Versus the current method: