Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-13 Thread rusi
On Jul 13, 5:22 am, CM cmpyt...@gmail.com wrote: On Jul 12, 5:18 pm, rantingrick rantingr...@gmail.com wrote: Kevin made the argument earlier that Tkinter (and others) are so easy to use that they render needing a GUI builder useless -- and he is correct! But did you know that there are

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread Steven D'Aprano
Thorsten Kampe wrote: * sturlamolden (Mon, 11 Jul 2011 06:44:22 -0700 (PDT)) On 11 Jul, 14:39, Ben Finney ben+pyt...@benfinney.id.au wrote: The Unix model is: a collection of general-purpose, customisable tools, with clear standard interfaces that work together well, and are easily

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread Andrew Berg
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: RIPEMD160 On 2011.07.12 05:24 AM, Steven D'Aprano wrote: Rather than taking advantage of that convenience, commercial vendors put barriers in the way and try to carve out little walled gardens. Did they not learn anything from AOL? DRM and activation

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread Chris Angelico
On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 8:24 PM, Steven D'Aprano steve+comp.lang.pyt...@pearwood.info wrote: Where is the Windows equivalent of yum or apt-get? Why isn't there a central repository of independent and third party Windows software? It seems clear to me that it is the major open source communities

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread CM
One reason there hasn't been much demand for a GUI builder is that, in many cases, it's just as simpler or simpler to code a GUI by hand. I use a GUI builder because I'd rather click less than type more. I just tried that in Boa Constructor; with ~10 mouse clicks I produced 964 characters of

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread rantingrick
On Jul 12, 1:43 pm, CM cmpyt...@gmail.com wrote: One reason there hasn't been much demand for a GUI builder is that, in many cases, it's just as simpler or simpler to code a GUI by hand. I use a GUI builder because I'd rather click less than type more. I just tried that in Boa

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-12 Thread CM
On Jul 12, 5:18 pm, rantingrick rantingr...@gmail.com wrote: On Jul 12, 1:43 pm, CM cmpyt...@gmail.com wrote: One reason there hasn't been much demand for a GUI builder is that, in many cases, it's just as simpler or simpler to code a GUI by hand. I use a GUI builder because I'd

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 02:43, Adam Tauno Williams awill...@whitemice.org wrote: Because RAD tools are for GUI toolkits, not for languages. If you're using GTK, Glade works fine. Same with QT and QTDesigner. If you're using WPF with IronPython, t These [Glade, etc...] are *NOT* RAD tools.  They are GUI

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 00:50, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I mean what

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread bruno.desthuilli...@gmail.com
On Jul 11, 2:42 am, Adam Tauno Williams awill...@whitemice.org wrote: But Open Source land is simply too fragmented.  There are too many database bindings [and RAD requires something like an ORM (think SQLalchemy)] and far too many GUI toolkits [Qt, Gtk, wx, and the list goes on and on].

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Ben Finney
bruno.desthuilli...@gmail.com bruno.desthuilli...@gmail.com writes: On Jul 11, 2:42 am, Adam Tauno Williams awill...@whitemice.org wrote: But Open Source land is simply too fragmented.  There are too many database bindings [and RAD requires something like an ORM (think SQLalchemy)] and

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 14:39, Ben Finney ben+pyt...@benfinney.id.au wrote: The Unix model is: a collection of general-purpose, customisable tools, with clear standard interfaces that work together well, and are easily replaceable without losing the benefit of all the others. This is opposed to the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Kevin Walzer
On 7/10/11 6:50 PM, Ivan Kljaic wrote: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I mean what happened to boa

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Thorsten Kampe
* sturlamolden (Mon, 11 Jul 2011 06:44:22 -0700 (PDT)) On 11 Jul, 14:39, Ben Finney ben+pyt...@benfinney.id.au wrote: The Unix model is: a collection of general-purpose, customisable tools, with clear standard interfaces that work together well, and are easily replaceable without losing the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 16:10, Thorsten Kampe thors...@thorstenkampe.de wrote: And as soon as developers start developing for Unix customers (say Komodo, for instance), they start following the Windows model - as you call it. You are probably aware that Unix and Unix customers have been around since the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Chris Angelico
On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 12:21 AM, sturlamolden sturlamol...@yahoo.no wrote: You are probably aware that Unix and Unix customers have been around since the 1970s. I would expect the paradigm to be changed by now. The paradigm of small tools that do exactly what they're supposed to, and can be

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Thorsten Kampe
* sturlamolden (Mon, 11 Jul 2011 07:21:37 -0700 (PDT)) On 11 Jul, 16:10, Thorsten Kampe thors...@thorstenkampe.de wrote: And as soon as developers start developing for Unix customers (say Komodo, for instance), they start following the Windows model - as you call it. You are probably

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread rusi
On Jul 11, 7:39 pm, Chris Angelico ros...@gmail.com wrote: On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 12:21 AM, sturlamolden sturlamol...@yahoo.no wrote: You are probably aware that Unix and Unix customers have been around since the 1970s. I would expect the paradigm to be changed by now. The paradigm of

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Speedbird
On Windows, you're a customer and the developer wants to make using his application as convenient as possible for you, the customer. So the well-behavioured, good-intentioned windows devs are making sure the customer feels pampered and cozy, how nice and dandy. On Unix you don't pay and the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Stefan Behnel
Ivan Kljaic, 11.07.2011 00:50: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. Just a quick suggestion regarding the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread rantingrick
On Jul 11, 11:33 am, rusi rustompm...@gmail.com wrote: A gui-builder reduces the semantic gap by showing a widget when the programmer things 'widget.' Banging out hundreds of lines in vi/emacs for the same purpose does a measurably poorer job. It is very rare to need to bang out hundreds of

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Chris Angelico
On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 2:56 AM, rantingrick rantingr...@gmail.com wrote: It is very rare to need to bang out hundreds of lines of code to replace a mouse click interface. If properly designed a good API can compete with a GUI. In far less time than it takes me to scroll down a list of

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Ivan Kljaic
Ok. I asked about this questio because I am working with python for the last 5 years and I am always in touch about signifigact things in Python. I am pissed of that I make my living by developing applications at work in Java an C#. My comPany would switch to python but they complained that there

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread rantingrick
On Jul 11, 1:03 pm, Chris Angelico ros...@gmail.com wrote: The one time where point and click is majorly superior to scripted design is with pixel positioning of widgets. You can drag things around until you're artistically happy with them, rather than have to fiddle with the numbers in code.

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Elias Fotinis
On Mon, 11 Jul 2011 20:11:56 +0300, Stefan Behnel stefan...@behnel.de wrote: Just a quick suggestion regarding the way you posed your question. It's usually better to ask if anyone knows a good tool to do a specific job (which you would describe in your post), instead of complaining about there

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Chris Angelico
On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 4:28 AM, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: For how many years are this vui library wars going on. How many. Look. I am a open source supporter but Windows will always kick the ass of open source because the open source comunity can not make a decision. You think

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread rantingrick
On Jul 11, 1:28 pm, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: To summarize it. It would be very helpfull for python to spread if there qould be one single good rad gui builder similar to vs or netbeAns but for python. Well don't hold your breath friend because i have been ranting for years about

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Chris Angelico
On Tue, Jul 12, 2011 at 4:52 AM, rantingrick rantingr...@gmail.com wrote: As we all know you only need three types of geometry management:  * Linear (horizontalvertical)  * Grid  * Absolute I contend that Absolute is unnecessary and potentially dangerous. Grid and Box (linear) are the most

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Andrew Berg
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: RIPEMD160 On 2011.07.11 02:16 PM, Chris Angelico wrote: You think Microsoft makes decisions and sticks with them? Look at Office's last few versions. They can't decide on a file format, an interface, a featureset... everything keeps changing. Of

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 20:28, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: To summarize it. It would be very helpfull for python to spread if there qould be one single good rad gui builder similar to vs or netbeAns but for python. So right now if i need to make a gui app i need to work with an applicatio that is

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 21:58, sturlamolden sturlamol...@yahoo.no wrote: That's eight. Sorry, nine ;) -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 20:28, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: The ony worthly ones mentioning as an gui builder are boa constructor fo wx, qtDesigner with the famous licence problems why companies do not want to work with it, sharpdevelop for ironpython and netbeans for jython. There is

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread cjrh
On Monday, 11 July 2011 00:50:31 UTC+2, Ivan Kljaic wrote: But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I simply do not see any reasons why there isn't anything. Please help me understand it. Any insights? The set of reasons that nobody else has made one is *exactly* the

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 21:58, sturlamolden sturlamol...@yahoo.no wrote: http://wxformbuilder.org/ This Demo is using C++, it works the same with Python (wxPython code is generated similarly). http://zamestnanci.fai.utb.cz/~bliznak/screencast/wxfbtut1/wxFBTut1_controller.swf Sturla --

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Kevin Walzer
On 7/11/11 2:28 PM, Ivan Kljaic wrote: Did you notice that 2 of these 4 are not for python? One is out of dTe and one has a fucked up licence. Sorry guys but there is not even one single rad gui tool for python as long as there is no serious guibuilder. One reason there hasn't been much demand

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 11 Jul, 22:35, Kevin Walzer k...@codebykevin.com wrote: One reason there hasn't been much demand for a GUI builder is that, in many cases, it's just as simpler or simpler to code a GUI by hand. Often a GUI builder is used as a bad replacement for sketch-pad and pencil. With layout managers

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Dave Cook
On 2011-07-10, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I mean what happened to boa constructor that it stopped developing. I simply do not see any reasons why there isn't anything. I prefer spec-generators (almost

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Gregory Ewing
Chris Angelico wrote: either brain something'd (keeping this G-rated) or an orangutan, There's a certain librarian who might take issue with your lumping orangutans in with the brain-something'd... -- Greg -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread Ben Finney
Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com writes: My comPany would switch to python but they complained that there is not even one single gui builder or framework that can allow it to make a living from it. That response from your company is a non sequitur. What does “one single gui builder or framework”

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 12 Jul, 01:33, Dave Cook davec...@nowhere.net wrote: I prefer spec-generators (almost all generate XML these days) like QtDesigner to code-generators like Boa. I've only seen one good argument for code generation, and that's to generate code for a layout to see how it's done. But code

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-11 Thread sturlamolden
On 12 Jul, 01:33, Dave Cook davec...@nowhere.net wrote: I prefer spec-generators (almost all generate XML these days) like QtDesigner to code-generators like Boa. I've only seen one good argument for code generation, and that's to generate code for a layout to see how it's done.  But code

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread Corey Richardson
Excerpts from Ivan Kljaic's message of Sun Jul 10 18:50:31 -0400 2011: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python.

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread CM
On Jul 10, 6:50 pm, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I mean what

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread Benjamin Kaplan
On Sun, Jul 10, 2011 at 3:50 PM, Ivan Kljaic iklj...@gmail.com wrote: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python.

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread Adam Tauno Williams
On Sun, 2011-07-10 at 15:50 -0700, Ivan Kljaic wrote: Ok Guys. I know that most of us have been expiriencing the need for a nice Gui builder tool for RAD and most of us have been googling for it a lot of times. But seriously. Why is the not even one single RAD tool for Python. I mean what

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread Adam Tauno Williams
Because RAD tools are for GUI toolkits, not for languages. If you're using GTK, Glade works fine. Same with QT and QTDesigner. If you're using WPF with IronPython, t These [Glade, etc...] are *NOT* RAD tools. They are GUI designers. A RAD tool provides a GUI designer that can be bound to a

Re: Wgy isn't there a good RAD Gui tool fo python

2011-07-10 Thread Anthony Papillion
As someone who was a Visual Studio user for many years, I felt much the same way you do when I made the jump to Python on Linux last year. But then I discovered Glade and am quite satisfied. Glades UI design paradigm is a little different than that of VS but it's not so hard that you couldn't