Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread Q
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d807ec8$0$2501$db0fe...@news.zen.co.uk... David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ilprm0$3kv$1...@news.eternal-september.org... No reason not to downgrade, Q, if you don't need the fixes and features in the current

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread David J Taylor
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d887390$0$2524$da0fe...@news.zen.co.uk... [] Hi David, A reply from Garmin! Also I tried the downgrade - its in and working, though I'm not seeing much if any difference in the numbers yet - I should be able to post some data later in the week once its

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ima1lb$o0v$1...@news.eternal-september.org... From my tests on a Sure GPS board, it many be important to get NTP to look for the first sentence sent, although I guess you must already be down to a single NMEA

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:imandk$5ic$2...@news.eternal-september.org... I would prefer on-list, as others may be able to provide help and useful input. I'm not sure I can add more than is already on my Web pages. Yep - that's totally fine.

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread David J Taylor
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d88df4c$0$2514$db0fe...@news.zen.co.uk... [] If you have no objections it may be easier to take this 'off-list' and email you direct - it will save all the poor folk on here having to listen to my insane testing - once everything is working and playing nice I

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-22 Thread Q
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d88e97c$0$12167$fa0fc...@news.zen.co.uk... I need to have a clean up on this machine now, and I think I'm going to stick 2.6.37 kernel on it with native PPS support and see what happens. Scrap that - it wouldn't boot and hung on udev and I don't have time to

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-16 Thread David J Taylor
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d7fd7ae$0$2503$db0fe...@news.zen.co.uk... David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ilc6um$4s8$1...@news.eternal-september.org... To me it should be common courtesy to reply as soon as possible, even if it's just an

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-16 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ilprm0$3kv$1...@news.eternal-september.org... No reason not to downgrade, Q, if you don't need the fixes and features in the current firmware. I understand that some folk are running on firmware 3.20, Yes, I do

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-15 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ilc6um$4s8$1...@news.eternal-september.org... To me it should be common courtesy to reply as soon as possible, even if it's just an acknowledgement. You might learn more from a phone call Still no reply - but

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-10 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:il7bhl$vgg$1...@news.eternal-september.org... I hope that Garmin at least acknowledge your request - let's hope the delay means that it being passed on. Nothing yet - not even a robot responder telling my the form

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-10 Thread David J Taylor
Q ..@.. wrote in message news:4d79277a$0$2538$da0fe...@news.zen.co.uk... David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:il7bhl$vgg$1...@news.eternal-september.org... I hope that Garmin at least acknowledge your request - let's hope the delay means that it being

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-09 Thread David J Taylor
Hi David, I sent off the query/problem to them a few days ago via the online form - alas no reply as yet though. I've had problems my end anyway the box this is attached to decided to die and I had to replace the CPU which did all sorts of odd things with the clock and required a change of

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-03-08 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ijk0a0$ssp$1...@news.eternal-september.org... Ok I'll go back over your past posts re the problem and report it myself to Garmin UK and see what they say - once I get something back I'll let you know. I have 3.60

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-02-18 Thread David J Taylor
http://www.sureelectronics.net/goods.php?id=99 Thanks for the link! Even though I already have a big bunch of GPSs, I've placed an order for one of those kits. :-) I really liked the multiple interfaces, the ms precision for the NMEA timestamp and the total price which is below the minimum

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-02-17 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:ijhb50$ifm$1...@news.eternal-september.org... V3.60 was out at the start of Jan I think - but there is nothing in the notes to say this issue is resolved. Do we need to chase this with Garmin UK? Yes, we do. I've

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-02-17 Thread Terje Mathisen
David J Taylor wrote: I'm supposed to be on the Garmin RSS feed for updates, but I didn't see 3.60 announced. I've now downloaded a copy but, as you say, it doesn't claim to address the issue. I'm still waiting for my Sure Electronics equivalent to arrive from China:

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-02-17 Thread David J Taylor
Ok I'll go back over your past posts re the problem and report it myself to Garmin UK and see what they say - once I get something back I'll let you know. I have 3.60 running anyway with no new problems (that I can see) Thanks, Q, I can't see it doing any harm. Cheers, David

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-02-16 Thread Q
David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote in message news:igu5i1$hn9$1...@news.eternal-september.org... unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij3r1n.a4g.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] Your referent is somewhat unclear. If you are saying that

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-17 Thread Terje Mathisen
Jan Ceuleers wrote: On 16/01/11 09:11, Chris Albertson wrote: No, if it is not _processed right at the UTC second it is pointless. The Motorola GPS allows you to adjust the timing of the pulse to account for delay in the antenna feed line and serial line. I was also thinking about avoiding

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-16 Thread Chris Albertson
The only way to know is to compare to another reference assumed to be correct.  Pool NTP servers would be accurate enough for that.    The GPSes (Motorola Oncore) I use have a related problem in that they allow the pulse to be adjust so that it happens before the UTC second or any time during

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-16 Thread Jan Ceuleers
On 16/01/11 09:11, Chris Albertson wrote: No, if it is not _processed right at the UTC second it is pointless. The Motorola GPS allows you to adjust the timing of the pulse to account for delay in the antenna feed line and serial line. I was also thinking about avoiding interrupt collisions.

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-16 Thread Rob
Jan Ceuleers janspam.ceule...@skynet.be wrote: On 16/01/11 09:11, Chris Albertson wrote: No, if it is not _processed right at the UTC second it is pointless. The Motorola GPS allows you to adjust the timing of the pulse to account for delay in the antenna feed line and serial line. I was

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-16 Thread Jan Ceuleers
On 16/01/11 11:25, Rob wrote: Jan Ceuleersjanspam.ceule...@skynet.be wrote: I was also thinking about avoiding interrupt collisions. In an ideal world, if the PPS interrupt occurs exactly at the UTC second it is going to coincide with the system's timer interrupt, is it not? That's even if the

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij2ign.o9d.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] Is the start of the nmea sentect coming more than one second after the PPS signal? Or is it just ending at the one second mark? The start of the NMEA sentence can be /after/ the

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread Rob
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote: On 2011-01-14, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com wrote: When the software (any software) only receives a PPS signal and a serial message conveying the absolute time, but it does not know how much the serial message is offset from the true

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij14hc.qns.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] This is a problem in the coding of the program (gpsd?) that you are using to get the data. The computer

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-15, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij1g6n.mnc.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] ??? There is a program which takes the PPS signal and takes the nmea sentence and tells ntpd how much out

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij3r1n.a4g.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] Your referent is somewhat unclear. If you are saying that your unit is out of spec, then return it. When operated with earlier firmware, the unit is in spec, but may be out of spec

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-15 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij3r8s.a4g.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] So you are separating the PPS from the nmea, and wondering how to get them together again? The best way is for the same program to look at the PPS and the nmea so it can associate them.

[ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread David J Taylor
Folks, You may recall that I had a problem with a Garmin GPS18x LVC after firmware upgrades, where the offset between the leading edge of the PPS signal and the end of the NMEA serial data exceeded one second. With some help from Hal Murray who knows more of NTP than I do, we have worked

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread Miroslav Lichvar
On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 08:40:25AM -, David J Taylor wrote: Folks, You may recall that I had a problem with a Garmin GPS18x LVC after firmware upgrades, where the offset between the leading edge of the PPS signal and the end of the NMEA serial data exceeded one second. With some help

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: Folks, You may recall that I had a problem with a Garmin GPS18x LVC after firmware upgrades, where the offset between the leading edge of the PPS signal and the end of the NMEA serial data exceeded one second. With

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: Thanks for the information. I was curious about the new position averaging mode, but I'll wait until this is resolved. 1.0s offset is horrible, that will certainly break gpsd or any application that pairs pulses with

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij14l6.qns.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] Well 17ms would get you under the 1.0 sec cutoff. It seems that with ntpd there is no 1.0 sec cut-off - fortunately. Cheers, David ___

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com wrote: When the software (any software) only receives a PPS signal and a serial message conveying the absolute time, but it does not know how much the serial message is offset from the true time, how should it determine the true time?

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij14hc.qns.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] This is a problem in the coding of the program (gpsd?) that you are using to get the data. The computer

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread Chris Albertson
On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 1:30 PM, unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote: On 2011-01-14, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com wrote: When the software (any software) only receives a PPS signal and a serial message conveying the absolute time, but it does not know how much the serial

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-14, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com wrote: On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 1:30 PM, unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote: On 2011-01-14, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com wrote: When the software (any software) only receives a PPS signal and a serial message conveying

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread Hal Murray
In article AANLkTi=E0_9LzCDg9esXx7yZp_NJGmSU+cuS=FY9=8...@mail.gmail.com, Chris Albertson albertson.ch...@gmail.com writes: Could this be automated? Maybe, to some degree. The reference clock driver would need to have a survey mode setting where it would run for many hours and compare it's own

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij219b.cr7.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] The shmslp driver does something similar. It uses some other source to get the seconds right and then hands over to the PPS to get the nanoseconds right. But it uses only the PPS pulse,

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread David J Taylor
unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij1g6n.mnc.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] ??? There is a program which takes the PPS signal and takes the nmea sentence and tells ntpd how much out the computer clock is from the true time. If you are not using gpsd, you are

Re: [ntp:questions] GPX18x LVC 3.50 firmware - high serial delay problem workround

2011-01-14 Thread unruh
On 2011-01-15, David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk.invalid wrote: unruh un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca wrote in message news:slrnij1g6n.mnc.un...@wormhole.physics.ubc.ca... [] ??? There is a program which takes the PPS signal and takes the nmea sentence and tells ntpd how much out