[R] RandomForest ... Always Returning a 1?

2012-02-05 Thread apresley
We have a pretty simple R forecasting problem, using randomForest. Our script is below. We have data with about 6 columns, and 625 rows to do the training on, and then we're trying to forecast 90 or so rows. The x matrix has 3 years worth of sales data, starting at 6:15am. However, for some

Re: [R] RandomForest ... Always Returning a 1?

2012-02-05 Thread Peter Langfelder
Well, if you look at your data more carefully, you will see that the histogram of y is heavily skewed towards 1 (small values). The 91/625 quantile is still 1 (there are 192 1s). It is therefore not surprising that RF comes up with mostly 1s (in my attempt it came up with two 2s, but that is a bit

Re: [R] RandomForest ... Always Returning a 1?

2012-02-05 Thread Anthony Presley
Peter, Thanks for checking on this! We're having some difficulties forecasting sales ... randomForest is doing a great job on days and periods where there is high variability. However, such as in this case, we do get dates/times/departments where it simply forecasts the most frequent value (I