Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-19 Thread Richard Lawrence
On Sunday, August 17, 2014 3:41:03 AM UTC-7, Peter Adler wrote: There are roll-top pannier people, and there are flappy-top pannier people. The only way to find out which one you *really* are is to buy the other kind of panniers, ride around with them for a while, and realize how much

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-18 Thread Peter Adler
There are roll-top pannier people, and there are flappy-top pannier people. The only way to find out which one you *really* are is to buy the other kind of panniers, ride around with them for a while, and realize how much you hate them. I used to ride around town with a full set of purple

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-16 Thread 'hangtownmatt' via RBW Owners Bunch
Anne, I think your are reading way too much into this. Back when Carsick first started making bags I wanted one of their barrel bags. At that time it was my impression the wife ran the business and he made the bags. She responded to all my e-mails, was willing to meet me personally on a

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-16 Thread Ron Mc
you have a good point Matt. Reviewing my e-mails from Brian and Monica when we were waiting for olive canvas from their supplier, I had many more contacts with Monica. On Saturday, August 16, 2014 11:11:19 AM UTC-5, hangtownmatt wrote: Anne, I think your are reading way too much into this.

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-16 Thread Richard Lawrence
Hi Anne, Thanks for your advice! On Friday, August 15, 2014 11:48:55 AM UTC-7, Anne Paulson wrote: I have Ortlieb roll-top panniers, which I have used on many long and short tours. Would you choose the Ortliebs over either the Carsick or SackVille panniers for touring and camping? If

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-16 Thread Patrick Moore
Thanks, Richard! My question exactly, who not too long ago traded Ortlieb Packer Pluses for Rollers. For my own uses, largely grocery getting, the Rollers are better because they have a much simpler closing system -- no flap, neck, drawstring, multiple super-imposed straps. But I am puzzled as to

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-16 Thread Anne Paulson
I would choose the Ortliebs over the Carsick or Sackville panniers because the Ortliebs have a better attachment mechanism. The hooks lock onto your rack, wrapping completely around the rack. To engage them, you just put the hook over the rack and push down. To disengage, you pull up the handle,

[RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-15 Thread Richard Lawrence
Hi everyone, I am looking for a set of panniers, and I've been considering both a set from Carsick Designs and the Sackville TourSacks for my new-to-me Sam. I've seen a few people on the list recommend the Carsick panniers, and a few people express mild dissatisfaction with the TourSacks. I

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-15 Thread Anne Paulson
My son has a pair of the TourSacks. I think I bought them on sale. They remain permanently attached to his Rambouillet, which he uses for commuting. I have Ortlieb roll-top panniers, which I have used on many long and short tours. If I were choosing between Carsick and TourSack for touring, I'd

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-15 Thread Ron Mc
I love my Carsick panniers. They are heavy duty, also heavy, but they really load up. Work great on a Nitto rack, and the roll top makes them very versatile. On Friday, August 15, 2014 1:48:55 PM UTC-5, Anne Paulson wrote: My son has a pair of the TourSacks. I think I bought them on sale.

Re: [RBW] Panniers: Carsick vs. Sackville opinions?

2014-08-15 Thread Anne Paulson
One random thing I'm going to add, though. Here's some text from a Carsick page: Trying to talk your gal into going on a bicycle tour with you? This one-of-a-kind set of bicycle panniers might just be the answer. (If she likes pink camo). They are light, roomy, and look sharp! Apparently, in