[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-13 Thread Way Rebb
I've been thinking about going from 46 to 44. I just swapped out a 10cm stem for an 8 on the Hillborne and its like a new bike. I think a little narrower bar would bring it all together. I've also been checking out the Compass Randonneur bars but they seem to be 38.5 or something. They look

[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread newenglandbike
I agree with Charlie- the wide ones seem better for offroad riding. Still, I traded 46s I had on my Bombadil for 42s last year and don't want to go back.I must have to to do with my narrow bird-like shoulders :DBottom line for me though either size of Noodle bar are the best bars

[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread Mike
On Feb 12, 4:19 am, robert zeidler zeidler.rob...@gmail.com wrote: Likewise, this is why I've never agreed with a narrow Q-factor being best for all. It mskes sense thst if shoulders are wider hips will be also. I have to agree with Robert on this. My randonneuring bike has VO TA knock-offs

[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread Eric
What's your shoulder width? On Feb 11, 4:39 pm, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: I just swapped out the 46 cm Noodles for a pair of 42s (thanks, Dylan -- I'll mail the 46s this coming week) and I must say that I much prefer the narrower ones. I've got them at the same height and reach

[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread Alex Moll
Gotta be something to do with shoulder width. I love my 48 noodles. The narrow bars are really to only thing I don't love about my vintage rides. They handle great with the narrow bars, but I'm just not as comfortable. I'm a little bigger than average at 6'3 200lbs. Alex On Feb 11, 7:00 pm,

Re: [RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Haven't measured that or my PBH. I'm not huge; slender build, 5'10 of height mostly in the torso (Asian, not a dwarf); ride anything from a 57 to a 60 depending on tt length; 42 or so long and 16 1/2 - 33-34: so middle size. I think the 42s will be fine off road. I tend to use the hoods and ramps

Re: [RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-12 Thread Ryan Watson
I'm the freak who needs 48cm bars and a 120mm q-factor! On Feb 12, 2012, at 7:11, Mike mjawn...@gmail.com wrote: On Feb 12, 4:19 am, robert zeidler zeidler.rob...@gmail.com wrote: Likewise, this is why I've never agreed with a narrow Q-factor being best for all. It mskes sense thst if

[RBW] Re: 46 Noodles swapped for 42s

2012-02-11 Thread charlie
Wide bars are nice for off road but I find the narrower ones more comfy for road riding. I think Grants bias is due to having either long arms and wide shoulders or a preference for more control in off road situations.just mt guess. On Feb 11, 4:39 pm, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: