[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-20 Thread Ginz
Reporting back: I found an old but lightly used Shimano XCE braze-on front der. on eBay. I swapped it for the IRD Alpina-d and, sure enough, the action of my Silver shifter is a bit easier on my thumb. Perhaps the lever arm provides more leverage or the spring is a bit lighter. Either way, I'm

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-12 Thread Ginz
Since I need a braze-on front der. that will work with a 26/36/46, I ordered an old, cheap Shimano from eBay. I swear that the lever arm (near the cable anchor) on my IRD der. is ironically not providing enough leverage when combined with the Silver shifter. I'll report back on this combo in a

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread BCDrums
It's hard to know which derailer has a matching radius without being able to hold it up to the chainring. I'm beginning to lean to the IRD because it states that it is designed for the big ring I have. Other derailers just list a maximum ring size. BC On May 8, 9:37 am, Bill Lucas

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread MichaelH
I run the campy racing triple on a 48/34/26 triple and a 44/30 double. I works very well, much better than the 105's it replaced. It has a very short cage, which allows it to be set very low without interfering with the chain stay. michael On May 8, 4:57 pm, BCDrums bcdr...@comcast.net wrote:

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Ginz
I'm using the IRD with a Silver bar end shifter and I find that it takes an awful lot of force to shift to the big cog. I literally tore a ligament in my thumb on it. Anyone else had success increasing leverage of the cable's pull? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Ginz
Oh, and I'm running a 26/36/46 and other than the above issue, the IRD shifts perfectly. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com. To unsubscribe from this group,

Re: [RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-05-09 at 06:07 -0700, Ginz wrote: I'm using the IRD with a Silver bar end shifter and I find that it takes an awful lot of force to shift to the big cog. I literally tore a ligament in my thumb on it. Anyone else had success increasing leverage of the cable's pull? Something

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Ginz
Steve, Sorry, I wasn't clear. I hurt my thumb shifting to the big chainring. I had a habit of grabbing the bar end shifter and prying with my thumb like a can opener. Ginz -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to this

Re: [RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-05-09 at 06:30 -0700, Ginz wrote: Steve, Sorry, I wasn't clear. I hurt my thumb shifting to the big chainring. I had a habit of grabbing the bar end shifter and prying with my thumb like a can opener. I still don't see how that's possible. The shifter is usually slightly

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Alex
I actually had the same problem with the IRD - the spring inside it seemed to be immensely powerful, requiring me to tighten my shifter to keep from autoshifting and requiring a lot of force to shift to a bigger chainring. I switched back to the shimano altus from 1981 that my bike originally had

Re: [RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-05-09 at 08:45 -0700, Alex wrote: On the thumb debate: I think the confusion stems from the use of the word downshift - what Ginz meant (I think) is that he had to push down on the shifter a lot in order to shift to a bigger chainring. You do not push down on the shifter to

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread William
Steve P How can you not use your thumb? Do you really shift your left barcon by lifting it with your fingers while your thumb is floating in the air? I tried manipulating my left barcon without using my thumb, and it feels awkward and terribly imprecise, not to mention pointless. I don't have

Re: [RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread erik jensen
can i have your old xt? i love old fd's! erik On Mon, May 9, 2011 at 12:10 PM, Steve Palincsar palin...@his.com wrote: On Mon, 2011-05-09 at 08:45 -0700, Alex wrote: On the thumb debate: I think the confusion stems from the use of the word downshift - what Ginz meant (I think) is that he

Re: [RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2011-05-09 at 12:57 -0700, William wrote: Steve P How can you not use your thumb? Do you really shift your left barcon by lifting it with your fingers while your thumb is floating in the air? I tried manipulating my left barcon without using my thumb, and it feels awkward and

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-09 Thread BCDrums
Picked the IRD up at the LBS today, they said they had plenty of 'em. It's listed on the IRD site and the Harris Cyclery site as available. Will put it on the bike next rainy day and see what it can do. (Shift, I imagine...) BC On May 8, 10:26 am, Saturday Mark saturdaycyc...@gmail.com wrote:

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-08 Thread Saturday Mark
The IRD triple is great, however it has been out of stock for quite some time. Good luck finding one. The current Tiagra triple seems to work fine. Other than that you are probably going to have to scour Ebay and Craigslist... -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

[RBW] Re: Front derailer for 48-38-24: Shimano, Campy, IRD?

2011-05-08 Thread Bill Lucas
BC, The IRD Aplina is not a copy of the Ultegra. I used it to replace a 9-speed Ultegra on a 48-34-24 set up. The Ultegra was VERY fussy to get working. I literally bolted the IRD in place, adjusted the stops and it works perfectly. All that said, I tried one on my wife's new Ebisu