Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-16 Thread samh
Does anyone have a good methodology for repainting a damaged chain stay? On Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:11:02 PM UTC-6, William wrote: Chainsuck definitely is a huge bummer. It would be an even more huge a bummer to have it happen on a brand new bike. Like Garth, I'm grateful to have

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-13 Thread Jude
On Mar 11, 2:31 pm, Cyclofiend Jim cyclofi...@earthlink.net wrote: Hmmm... downhill with low-load and brand new components is definitely weird.  I'd suspect a stiff chain link before blaming an inherent design flaw. Count me as another user who experienced this. Maiden voyage of my Atlantis.

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-13 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Be careful with this method. I've done that and ended up with a severely bent chainring and permanently deformed (twisted) chain, not to mention new gouges on the chainstay. I finally installed a preventer device. On Wed, Mar 13, 2013 at 9:24 AM, Jude jeic...@gmail.com wrote: On Mar 11, 2:31

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-13 Thread Garth
On Monday, March 11, 2013 4:41:22 PM UTC-4, Shoji Takahashi wrote: Thanks, Jim, RE: conjecture. Does chain suck happen more often with certain types of derailers? I would guess that ones with weaker chain-tensioner springs would chain suck more often. (Perhaps something w/long cage vs

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-13 Thread William
Chainsuck definitely is a huge bummer. It would be an even more huge a bummer to have it happen on a brand new bike. Like Garth, I'm grateful to have never had a bad instance of it. As a shop mechanic, I've seen it plenty. If somebody challenged me to force it to happen on a brand new

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-13 Thread Cyclofiend
On Mar 13, 2013, at 10:22 AM, Garth wrote: That may be part of it, as well as monkey see problem in another, monkey start to have problem. The springs in modern derailers are weak compared to those from even the 7,8 speed ones. I have a Shimano LX rear 9sp. that flops the chain all

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-12 Thread dougP
Another consideration may be chain length. Sheldon has a procedure for optimizing chain length. I followed it a time or two but it only required taking out a link or 2, so I went back to just installing them as-is out of the packaging. Thinking back on it, I can't recall a chain suck event

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-11 Thread samh
I guess I must have good enough technique to not to have experienced it ;) I really don't think it has anything to do with shifting technique. I have triple's on mountain bikes that get muddy, and I've never experienced chain suck while riding them. Sometimes my mountain bikes are sporting

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-11 Thread Cyclofiend Jim
Hmmm... downhill with low-load and brand new components is definitely weird. I'd suspect a stiff chain link before blaming an inherent design flaw. (And just to restate it, we're talking about chainsuck with the chain not letting go of the chainring from the 6 o'clock position, and climbing

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-11 Thread Tom Goodmann
Your conjecture makes a lot of sense to me, Jim: chain slack might be the leading element, suggesting careful maintenance in that regard. I'm new to Rivendells, and as I check out frames for sale, I can't help but notice the frequency of scarring to the drive-side stay, so I asked. On Mon, Mar

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-11 Thread Shoji Takahashi
Thanks, Jim, RE: conjecture. Does chain suck happen more often with certain types of derailers? I would guess that ones with weaker chain-tensioner springs would chain suck more often. (Perhaps something w/long cage vs short cage given the chain angle.) Seems like the chain-suck descriptions

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread Garth
I've been riding triples since the early 80's ... never once have I experienced chain suck . I keep my FD perfectly tuned however, and I guess I must have good enough technique to not to have experienced it ;) -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread Joe Bernard
Bad chainrings, bad derailer adjustment, bad shifting technique, bad karma...the causes are endless, but they all lead back to one common denominator: Triple cranks. I'm so tired of the issue that I eschewed triples and front derailers altogether, and put a 2-speed FSA Patterson Transmission

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread Shoji Takahashi
There are devices to protect against chain suck. Essentially, they block the chain from coming up with the chain ring. RR36 has a few pics of commercially available devices (don't know if they're still around) and a homemade zip-tie version. Seems like some cranks/chain ring combos are more

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread samh
Over-shifting? (missing a gear or two or three) Shifting hard on a climb? Neither throwing a chain (to the outside) or dropping a chain (to the inside) is the same as chain suck. This is what chainsuck is: The general reason is that the chain does not disengage from the bottom of the inner

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
I had one of these -- forget maker -- installed by a LBS after the last disastrous (bent not only chainring but chain!) suck event. $14.99 full retail, IIRC. Should have installed one the first time suck happened. I've made ad hoc suck prevention devices out of hose clamps strategically placed;

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread Tonester
I was experiencing some granny gear chain suck on my new-to-me 82 Stumpjumper after replacing the chain. Turns out the old chain and the granny ring had developed an affinity for each other, one that was not carried into the relationship with the new chain. A trip to RBW and a new Sugino 26t

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-08 Thread Cyclofiend Jim
A lot of times, you can flip the ring and remount - watch for bolt heads contacting the frame if one side has recesses for the bolts. - J -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-07 Thread dougP
Tom: My experiences with chain suck have occurred when shifting between the middle inner chainring. When it happens, the chain is mostly on the inner ring BUT some of it has gotten sucked between the middle ring chainstay, resulting in paint removal at the least much tugging cursing at

[RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-07 Thread Deacon Patrick
Until today, the only chain suck I've had was user ineptitude. But I managed to gunk up my chain rings on a gloriously sloppy ride and they too a few miles to self-clean (the primary means my Hunqa has of getting clean). With abandon, Patrick On Thursday, March 7, 2013 7:32:14 PM UTC-7, Tom

Re: [RBW] Re: Noob question of the week: what's the deal with chain suck?

2013-03-07 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Thu, 2013-03-07 at 19:24 -0800, Deacon Patrick wrote: Until today, the only chain suck I've had was user ineptitude. But I managed to gunk up my chain rings on a gloriously sloppy ride and they too a few miles to self-clean (the primary means my Hunqa has of getting clean). A friend of