[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-14 Thread Savvas
Bill, Patrick and others, I don't know where all of you are, but if you are trying to purchase via on-line stores that are out of stock, why not just try buying directly from Carradice? I have done so on 2-3 occasions with a great outcome everytime, especially as I have had my questions

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread Bill M.
SJS advertises the Camper, but they don't have any stock. Neither does Wiggle, and when I tried to order one last year the delivery date just got pushed out further and further. I finally decided to stick with my ancient Nelson Longflap. Of course the Saddlesacks are also out of stock so

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Wiggles' site says mid October, maybe. Don't know. May well just get another rack -- the fomenter of this ferment (so to speak) was growing dissatisfaction with my custom rack: as in a marriage or a new car, the little defects become apparent with intimacy including being a wee bit off-center and

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread Jay in Tel Aviv
I have never seen the other Carradice saddle bags in person, but I really like my Super C. I chose it over the others for the convenience of the modern fittings vs leather straps for commuting. The shopping experience was bad enough that Evans stopped carrying most Carradice products and refunded

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Thanks, Jay -- the Super C is definitely a contender tho' it lacks the long flap. I figure what, $140 or so shipped from Wiggle? On Sat, Oct 13, 2012 at 9:57 AM, Jay in Tel Aviv jayin...@gmail.com wrote: I have never seen the other Carradice saddle bags in person, but I really like my Super C.

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread Jay in Tel Aviv
50 quid at SJS - Out of stock. Wiggle too. Carradice makes great bags that are next to impossible to buy. On Oct 13, 6:08 pm, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks, Jay -- the Super C is definitely a contender tho' it lacks the long flap. I figure what, $140 or so shipped from Wiggle?

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread Peter Morgano
There is a Sackville medium on ebay right now. On Oct 13, 2012 12:26 PM, Jay in Tel Aviv jayin...@gmail.com wrote: 50 quid at SJS - Out of stock. Wiggle too. Carradice makes great bags that are next to impossible to buy. On Oct 13, 6:08 pm, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks,

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Peter: do you have the link or auction #? My searches for Sackville, saddlebag, Rivendell etc don't turn it up. Thanks, Patrick On Sat, Oct 13, 2012 at 2:32 PM, Peter Morgano uscpeter11...@gmail.com wrote: There is a Sackville medium on ebay right now. On Oct 13, 2012 12:26 PM, Jay in Tel

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread Jim Mather
I was just looking at it (not buying though): http://www.ebay.com/itm/Rivendell-saddlesack-medium-/230864980164?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0hash=item35c0a008c4 On Sat, Oct 13, 2012 at 3:05 PM, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: Peter: do you have the link or auction #? My searches for Sackville,

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-13 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Thanks, just bought it. (I think -- these damn' computer transactions always leave me a bit confused.) Seller: are you on list? If so, the system charged me $15.43 for shipping even tho' the conditions on the auction page include free shipping for buy it now. Can you please refund the $15.43 via

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-12 Thread mr.trout
i ripped the pockets off of my longflap camper and have been rolling it up and placing it on the top of my rack, between two panniers full of camping gear. when i get into town i unroll it, stuff it with food, ice and beer. the bag is waterproof, at least enough to act as a cooler for the rest

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-11 Thread ekoral
I love my long flap. I've packed it majorly full with a tent, poles, sleepingbag, clothes, and dinner for two on more than one occasion (bike camping with a roadie friend who made me carry everything). I think it's great. if you pop it on a marks rack or similar small rear rack, it gets it

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread Christopher Murray
Howdy, I have had both and found the quality of Sackville to be much better- materials and construction. The quality of the Carradice was good just not as good. Usability I thought was about the same- they are both bags that attach to you saddle and carry things. I agree that you would

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread Christopher Chen
On Tuesday, October 9, 2012 12:16:45 PM UTC-7, Patrick Moore wrote: Those of you who have used both, which is better? I am inclined toward the Carradice (24 liters versus SM at 23+ when stuffed) since SJS has it for GBL 55. Anyone? I vote for the third party candidate, the Sackville

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread Matt Beebe
I have both- the Saddlesack M in conjunction with an R14 or Mark's rack is better for carrying books and what not, and the straps are easier to use, as Scot pointed out. It's just a well thought-out design.With the Large size version, you can fit a medium or large flat-rate if it fits

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread Matt Beebe
I have been using a Sackville medium to commute to work for over a year, after having used Longflaps, and Baggins bags, and definitely recommend the Sackville.I like it so much I also have a large that comes out for big stuff- it will fit those if it fits it ships boxes from USPS. I love

[RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread Manuel Acosta
+1 for the sackville large. You ALWAYS need more room. But if you have to chose between those two get the sackville. I find how the Carradice sits so the side pockets have the tendency for stuff to fall out. This could be my absentmindedness of me not strapping the sides. Rivendell's

Re: [RBW] Re: Speaking of luggage: Camper longflap versus Sackville medium

2012-10-10 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Thanks for all the replies; the Sackville Medium seems the poll winner by a large margin. While realizing that, I've used many different Carradices including several Campers -- damn sure wish I'd kept one -- and know that it works pretty well and at 2/3 the price ... We'll see what the financial