Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-07 Thread William
Btw, who ever said chain stays are always symmetrical? By the way, who ever said my two legs are symmetrical? On Saturday, August 3, 2013 6:50:42 PM UTC-7, Peter Pesce wrote: I'm thinking that a few mm one way or another just doesn't matter. Some will say they notice. Some will say they

Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-07 Thread Garth
Exactly !!!Legs, hips, feet, etc. etc. . any time there is more than one of something, they are never exactly equal ! On Wednesday, August 7, 2013 6:46:24 PM UTC-4, William wrote: By the way, who ever said my two legs are symmetrical? -- You received this message because

Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-07 Thread Ron Mc
I get it the other way. I put a SKS symmetric bottom bracket on my old Raleigh for a Cyclotouriste triple. The weird 73mm Raleigh socket is not recommended for spacers to make it asymmetric. So my pedals are exactly the same width from the frame.

[RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-03 Thread JL
I was giving my commuter bike CBO a quick check over and noticed that the crankset sits asymetric to the frame. It has never bothered me but my question is - aside from cranks that are made offset so an asymetrical BB actually aligns them symetrically - what is the purpose of asymetrical BBs?

Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-03 Thread Patrick Moore
AFAIK, the reason is to get as small a Q as possible while allowing sufficient clearance for the stays and proper chainline. I think this was particularly popular in the old days for triples -- the right stuck out further to accommodate proper chain line. I could lose ~5 mm on my XD2 if I could

Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-03 Thread JL
So the theory is that low q is ranked higher than having one's legs/feet/ankles rotating in different circles? That doesn't sit right with me but i am probably over thinking it. Rivendell's advocacy of pedaling free would address this issue but I don't care for it. It doesn't bother me on my

Re: [RBW] why asymetric?

2013-08-03 Thread Peter Pesce
I'm thinking that a few mm one way or another just doesn't matter. Some will say they notice. Some will say they don't. If you can get the inner ring of your triple to clear then maybe it's all good. Btw, who ever said chain stays are always symmetrical? - Pete in CT -- You received this