Issues in Applying RDA in Non-MARC Metadata Communities

2006-02-06 Thread Diane I. Hillmann
Issues in Applying RDA in Non-MARC Metadata Communities Diane I. Hillmann Jan. 31, 2006 Having come rather late to the RDA discussion, I recognize that the points I bring up in this document may not be the comments that CC:DA or JSC expects or desires at this stage, but I hope the concerns

Re: Issues in Applying RDA in Non-MARC Metadata Communities

2006-02-06 Thread Bodling, Kurt
Diane Hillmann has given us some excellent food for thought. Kurt A. T. Bodling Digital Resources Cataloger State Library of Pennsylvania 333 Market St. Harrisburg, PA 17126-1745 http://www.statelibrary.state.pa.us/ The State Library of Pennsylvania ... Serving and Preserving a

Correspondences between AA2 and RDA rules

2006-02-06 Thread Ed Jones
While I realize it is probably too late for the draft of Part I, it would be helpful if future drafts of RDA rules could identify the AA2 rules (or parts of rules) to which they correspond or from which they were derived. I (and others) have spent a great deal of time trying to determine

Re: Issues in Applying RDA in Non-MARC Metadata Communities

2006-02-06 Thread J. McRee Elrod
Diane I. Hillmann [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Oftentimes, the RDA (like traditional cataloging) herds catalogers to make decisions about what is primary or secondary and relegates the latter to the notes area. It's refreshing to have someone step back from the trees and view the forest as Ms

Re: Correspondences between AA2 and RDA rules

2006-02-06 Thread Deborah Fritz
Excellent suggestion, Ed. Or perhaps even just a list of the new rules that are supposed to represent changes. Deborah --- Deborah Fritz MARC Database Consultant The MARC of Quality -- http://www.marcofquality.com/ Voice/Fax: (321) 676-1904 -Original Message- From: Resource