Re: Framework for a Bibliographic Future

2007-03-17 Thread Jonathan Rochkind
On Mar 16, 2007, at 8:16 PM, Philip Davis wrote: It is helpful to have set down the sequence of stages in bibliographic control as seen by the Dublin Core community, namely Model, Schema, Guidance, Encoding. To mirror this, I should tend to express the sequence as Statement of International Cata

Re: Framework for a Bibliographic Future

2007-03-17 Thread J. McRee Elrod
Jonathan Rochkind said: >I see the Model, Schema, Guidance and Encoding as _components_ of a >metadata system. The difficulty I see in dividing these components is that they may become discordant. They must be in tandem. The contradictions between AACR2 and MARC21 are cases in point, e.g., t

Re: Framework for a Bibliographic Future

2007-03-17 Thread Philip Davis
I have read through Framework for a Bibliographic Future carefully twice. I do not understand all of it but shall present my response to it in the hope of receiving further enlightenment. I am grateful to the authors for being 'not ones to leave well enough alone' and believe that we all need t