Re: [RDA-L] Items that are both in hard copy and PDF

2013-05-08 Thread J. McRee Elrod
kyler Felix asked: In your email you said two physical forms of the same resource. I thought that a hard copy and a PDF file would not both be physical resources? Would it be similar to, for example, a book with a CD Rom? In my experience, a CD-ROM with a book is usually supplementary or

[RDA-L] Items that are both in hard copy and PDF

2013-05-07 Thread Felix, Kyley
Hello cataloguers Do any of you catalogue items that are both hard copy and a PDF file in the one catalogue record? I realise it is probably not common practice, but this has been done in my workplace for years and now that I am starting to use RDA I'm unsure whether to continue and whether

Re: [RDA-L] Items that are both in hard copy and PDF

2013-05-07 Thread J. McRee Elrod
Kyley Felix asked: Do any of you catalogue items that are both hard copy and a PDF file in the one catalogue record? We did not with AACR2, because of differing fixed fields and GMD. We will not with RDA because of differing fixed fields and 33X. There is also the matter of ease of plating

Re: [RDA-L] Items that are both in hard copy and PDF

2013-05-07 Thread Adam L. Schiff
Kyley, These are two different manifestations and they are not issued together, so I don't think you can or should describe them as a multipart monograph. In RDA you would probably create two separate records, but you could probably just create a record for the print and then note the