Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-09-25 Thread Andrew Newton
On Thu, Sep 21, 2023 at 6:55 AM Pawel Kowalik wrote: > > 4. Schema languages give a false sense of conformance. Conformance > tools are far more important. > > Schema won't replace the conformance tools for sure, as not every constraint > or relation can be covered with schema. But it makes it a

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-09-21 Thread Pawel Kowalik
Hi, Some comments below. Am 31.08.23 um 19:56 schrieb Andrew Newton: On Thu, Aug 31, 2023 at 1:05 PM Mario Loffredo wrote: AFAIU, the definition of a standard JSON data description language has been a controversial matter for long. To my knowledge, the only DDL published as RFC that

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-09-11 Thread Sammy Mishal
Hi, Sami Here from D3serve Labs. Greatly Appreciate everyone's feedback. >From What I've read it seems that what I've perceived as discrepancies may be caused by: - The differences between RFC-7483 and RFC-9083. - The Huge Difference in response size from different RDAP APIs, due to a big number

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-08-31 Thread Andrew Newton
On Thu, Aug 31, 2023 at 1:05 PM Mario Loffredo wrote: > > AFAIU, the definition of a standard JSON data description language has been a > controversial matter for long. To my knowledge, the only DDL published as > RFC that could work is CDDL [RFC8610]. It was primarily created for CBOR but >

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-08-31 Thread Mario Loffredo
Hi Scott, as just posted by Gavin, have already worked on a JSON Schema for RDAP and used it to build a kind of crawler which was able to validate the RDAP responses against RFC7483. Obviously, have no problem to collaborate with everyone is willing to define a JSON Schema for RDAP but

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-08-31 Thread Gavin Brown
Hi there, Further to Scott’s email, some time ago Mario and Maurizio from .IT created some schemas which I pinched and put in this Git repository: https://github.com/gbxyz/rdap-json-schemas These are based on RFC 7483, but with a bit of work could be updated and form the basis of a draft. G.

Re: [regext] JSON Schema for RDAP RFC-9083

2023-08-31 Thread Hollenbeck, Scott
There is no RFC that I can find that describes JSON Schema. That’s not surprising, since when I did some reading on the web site described below I found references to multiple expired I-Ds: https://json-schema.org/specification.html The lack of a formal specification certainly contributed