Report Date: 08/22/2012 Reporters Name: Gabriel de Dietrich Package/Build date: 08/22/2012 Package name: qt-mac-opensource-5.0.0-beta1-offline.dmg Package type: Installer (Offline) Mkspec used: Seems to be macx-gcc ------------------------------------------------------------ Build checks: ------------------------------------------------------------ Asks about license: Not tested Compiles with minimal options: Not tested Compiles as static build (where supported): Not tested Compiles in namespace (where supported): Not tested Compiles with shadow build: Not tested Compiles cross-compiled (where supported): Not tested Comments:
------------------------------------------------------------ General checks: ------------------------------------------------------------ Text files have the correct EOL: Yes Files/dirs have sane perm. and timestamps: Yes Tags have been replaced properly: Yes README has valid information: Yes Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------ Installer checks: ------------------------------------------------------------ Fresh install works correctly: Yes Upgrade install works correctly: Not tested Parallel install works correctly: Not tested Previously installed package still works: Not tested Warns when installing over an installation: Not tested Is correctly signed: No Displays appropriate gfx & strings & version no.: Yes Offers the correct license(s): Yes Offers sane default install directory: No Correctly installs to default directory: Yes Correctly installs to non-default loc.: Not tested Sanely reports progress and completion: Yes Installs only selected components: Not tested Component selector works sanely: Yes Shortcuts from last page of installer works: Yes Correctly creates Desktop shortcuts: No Correctly creates Start Menu shortcuts: Not tested Sets correct environment variables for shell: Not tested Package shows up in Control Panel/Pkg. Manager: Yes Patching of files is done correctly: Not tested Cancel button is available: Yes Cleans up after install failure: Not tested Cleanly fails on insufficient disk space: Not tested Comments: On OS X 10.8, I got the "untrusted developer" warning when opening the install app. Install experience feels sub-standard. First, people tend to trust better install packages rather than install apps. Also, some of the installed apps are broken (e.g., Assistant), or shouldn't be there (e.g., syncqt). ------------------------------------------------------------ Uninstaller checks: ------------------------------------------------------------ Uninstalls properly: No Removes installed files properly: Not tested Removes empty directories: Not tested Removes registry keys: Not tested Reverses any other changes: Not tested Comments: MaintenaceTool app won't launch. ------------------------------------------------------------ Both source/binary package checks: ------------------------------------------------------------ License is correct: Yes Assistant works correctly: No Designer works correctly: No Demos and examples launch without crashing: Yes Demos and examples function acceptably: No Demos and examples can be rebuilt: Not tested External apps build: Not tested "DLL Swapping" work on an application: Not tested GUI stress-testing works ok: No Audio/Video w/QtMultimedia works: Not tested Raster engine works: Not tested Image formats work: Not tested GraphicsView works: Not tested OpenGL works: Not tested Printing works: Not tested QML 1 apps work (qmlviewer): No QML 2 apps work (qmlscene): Not tested QtNetwork works: Not tested QtSql works: Not tested QtSvg works: Not tested QtXml works: Not tested QtWebKit 1 works: Not tested QtWebkit 2 works: Not tested Comments: Qt 5 seems currently unusable on Mac. Notably, it seems there are many input related issues, like basic trackpad gestures not working. For instance, 2-finger scrolling would select what's lies under the cursor while scrolling. Is this package releasable?: No -- Report form at http://testresults.qt-project.org/forms/release-testing/index.pl submitted from 62.70.27.102 _______________________________________________ Releasing mailing list Releasing@qt-project.org http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/releasing
