RE: Ireland Charities Act 2009: Regulating the Sale of Catholic'Mass Cards'

2009-08-06 Thread Marc Stern
Does not US v Ballard (US 1944) state the applicable rule-which is (unsurprisingly) the rule Doug proposed? Marc Stern From: religionlaw-boun...@lists.ucla.edu [mailto:religionlaw-boun...@lists.ucla.edu] On Behalf Of Douglas Laycock Sent: Tuesday, August 04,

RE: Ireland Charities Act 2009: Regulating the Sale of Catholic'Mass Cards'

2009-08-06 Thread Eric Rassbach
Sorry, my earlier post was not clear - by Church in quotation marks I meant the defined term in the statute, not the word Church on the card. I agree completely with Doug and Marc. My point was only that if the Mass card said e.g. that a mass had been arranged to be said in a Roman Catholic

Francis Collins and Acceptable Criticisms

2009-08-06 Thread Anthony Decinque
Francis Collins has been selected to be the head of NIH, where he will have substantial authority to allocate the nation’s scientific research funding. There are a few criticisms of Mr. Collins being made regarding his religion. For this list, I wanted to set aside a specific criticism.

RE: Francis Collins and Acceptable Criticisms

2009-08-06 Thread Marc Stern
As a legal matter, the claim that someone's religious views are disqualifying comes close to, if not actually constituting a prohibited religious test for public office especially as the NIH to which Collins was nominated is a federal institution subject to the tests clause directly.However there

RE: Francis Collins and Acceptable Criticisms

2009-08-06 Thread Eric Rassbach
Isn't one of the lines to draw whether the idea is scientifically testable or not? We can make scientific observations now about whether the world rests upon turtles, but we cannot observe the birth of Christ. Also query whether the natural order we've been discussing isn't overly Newtonian

RE: Francis Collins and Acceptable Criticisms

2009-08-06 Thread Will Linden
At 04:35 PM 8/6/09 -0700, you wrote: explains his belief on the grounds that there's a probability, however infinitesimal, that he'll turn into a werewolf, would you be satisfied about his qualities? Turn INTO a werewolf? http://www.retaggr.com/SignatureProfile/wlinden