Re: [routing-wg] [db-wg] Last Call - creation of new out of region ROUTE(6) objects

2018-01-11 Thread denis walker via routing-wg
Hi Ronald I understand your viewpoint, but I think it is a bit harsh to criticise the judgement of the early developers of the routing system. As Sandra explained in this posthttps://www.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/db-wg/2017-October/005707.html the early model was based on ASs. Then as the

[routing-wg] Implementation of NWI-5 out of region ROUTE(6) objects

2018-02-12 Thread denis walker via routing-wg
Colleagues Based on the proposal by Tim for NWI-5 and the following discussions, the DB-WG co-chairs would like the RIPE NCC to schedule implementation of the following actions: -Remove the ASN authorisation requirement for ROUTE(6) object creation -Deprecate the "mnt-routes:" attribute in the

[routing-wg] Bad ROUTEs -- Fw: Weekly Routing Table Report

2018-10-19 Thread denis walker via routing-wg
Hi all Every week I get this email and usually just delete it. But as we have just been discussing cleaning up RIPE-NONAUTH I decided to look at it this week. I have some questions now. It includes these lines:Prefixes from unregistered ASNs in the Routing Table:                45     Number of

[routing-wg] source: RIPE may also contain invalid ROUTEs

2018-10-17 Thread denis walker via routing-wg
Hi guys There is a corner case where invalid ROUTE(6) objects may occur in the source: RIPE database. Before NWI-5 a ROUTE(6) object could be created either by the address space holder or the ASN holder. Both had to authorise the creation, but whoever created the object would maintain it.

Re: [routing-wg] source: RIPE may also contain invalid ROUTEs

2018-10-17 Thread denis walker via routing-wg
Routing Working Group Sent: Wednesday, 17 October 2018, 23:18 Subject: Re: [routing-wg] source: RIPE may also contain invalid ROUTEs Hi Denis, Can you point us to one example object? Kind regards, Job On Wed, Oct 17, 2018 at 22:23 denis walker via routing-wg wrote: Hi guys There is a corner case