[sage-devel] Re: Abelian groups are driving me crazy

2008-08-29 Thread John Cremona
2008/8/29 David Joyner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > I agree AbelianGroups needs rewriting and has odd behavior in > some cases. > > Incidently, here is what GAP does: > > gap> A := AbelianGroup([1,2,3]); > > gap> GeneratorsOfGroup(A); > [ of ..., f1, f2 ] > gap> A := AbelianGroup([2,1,3]); > > gap>

[sage-devel] Re: Abelian groups are driving me crazy

2008-08-29 Thread David Joyner
I agree AbelianGroups needs rewriting and has odd behavior in some cases. Incidently, here is what GAP does: gap> A := AbelianGroup([1,2,3]); gap> GeneratorsOfGroup(A); [ of ..., f1, f2 ] gap> A := AbelianGroup([2,1,3]); gap> GeneratorsOfGroup(A); [ f1, of ..., f2 ] This is kind of mid-way