[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Update of sr#110299 (group administration): Status:None => Works For Me Assigned to:None => ineiev Open/Closed:Open => Closed

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #9, sr #110299 (project administration): > > Why impossible? > > Because even a manager cannot remove a ticket from the system. It can only be closed. But you raise a valid point: my terminology was ambiguous--the typo can be _corrected_, but it can't be _undone_, so I

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #8, sr #110299 (project administration): [comment #7 comment #7:] > Why impossible? Because even a manager cannot remove a ticket from the system. It can only be closed. But you raise a valid point: my terminology was ambiguous--the typo can be _corrected_, but it can't be

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #7, sr #110299 (project administration): [comment #4 comment #4:] > A single typo should not result in a malformed submission that is impossible to correct. Why impossible? I just re-submit correctly, noting that the previous one was wrong, and tracker manager closes the

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #6, sr #110299 (project administration): As an experiment, when adding comment #5, I did not use the mouse to submit it, but hit "Shift-Tab Shift-Tab Shift-Tab Return," and it worked fine. So there are still keyboard-based submission options that don't involve implicit

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #5, sr #110299 (project administration): Alternately, if you consider Summary-field submission essential to some people's workflow, you could add a simple popup asking for confirmation, defaulting to No, when someone submits via that mechanism. Then implicit submission changes

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #4, sr #110299 (project administration): Another important consideration is how undoable the action is if the wrong key is hit. If I accidentally hit Enter while typing in a search box, submitting data before I intended, I have only to correct it and try again. If I

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #3, sr #110299 (project administration): Hi Bob, thanks for the reply. I'm not arguing against there being a keyboard method to submit a bug report. I'm arguing that the Summary field is a poor place for it. * When tabbing through fields in order, the user gets to the Summary

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #2, sr #110299 (project administration): Hello, But on the other side, not having an option for a user to fix their mistake (no matter why they made it) also leads to similar bug reports. In "majority" of cases we can recognise that the user sends uncompleted form (e.g. empty

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

Follow-up Comment #1, sr #110299 (project administration): Hello Dave, I am sorry that you were surprised by this behavior. However frankly I am surprised that you were surprised by it! This is the standard behavior of the web since forever. It has always been this way for literally all of

[sr #110299] minor typo submits unfinished bug report

URL: Summary: minor typo submits unfinished bug report Project: Savannah Administration Submitted by: barx Submitted on: Fri 28 Aug 2020 04:33:14 AM CDT Category: Savannah