Re: [SC-L] PCI: Boon or bust for software security?

2008-03-04 Thread Andy Murren
Overall I concur with Bruce on this. PCI has too broad of a constituent base to cover to be truly effective. Some fixes were added after the TJX breach, but look at how much TJX paid versus how much the laid aside to pay. I am betting that the TJX lawyers produced documents showing that they

Re: [SC-L] PCI: Boon or bust for software security?

2008-03-04 Thread Benjamin Tomhave
Worse than that, I think that until businesses universally understand the value of secure coding practices, they will resist the up-front cost to take on such a transformational program. SOX vs PCI would make for a good case study. SOX is very high level and generic, which led to much confusion

[SC-L] PCI: Boon or bust for software security?

2008-03-03 Thread Kenneth Van Wyk
Greetings SC-L, So here's a question to ponder. Now that PCI DSS 1.1 is out there (save a couple June 2008 deadlines still looming), has it been good or bad for software security as a whole? It does require secure development processes (as prescribed by OWASP). It does require sensitive