Re: [scots-l] Benjamin Franklin on Scottish music

2003-03-31 Thread Clarsaich
In a message dated 3/30/03 9:09:14 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: So the answer would be everything they would normally play when their instruments are dry  :-) Oh, my dear Toby. :-)  This is precisely why we use the term /damp/, not /dampen/, just to try and cut down on th

Re: [scots-l] Benjamin Franklin on Scottish music

2003-03-30 Thread Toby Rider
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In a message dated 3/28/03 5:16:57 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What would the repertoire of Scottish tunes that could be played effectively on an undamped wire harp be composed of? I would think that almost no tunes could be played effectiv

Re: [scots-l] Benjamin Franklin on Scottish music

2003-03-30 Thread Clarsaich
In a message dated 3/28/03 5:16:57 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What would the repertoire of Scottish tunes that could be played effectively on an undamped wire harp be composed of? Really old Scottish tunes. At least that's my hunch. Undamped on wire is undamped in the e

Re: [scots-l] Benjamin Franklin on Scottish music

2003-03-29 Thread Kate Dunlay or David Greenberg
Jack Campin wrote: he thought that the harmony arose from *successive* tones in the music - each note harmonizing with its predecessors, and the sequence of intervals being chosen to make this work, which implies a preference for melodic intervals wider than a tone. I don't know very much about ha

[scots-l] Benjamin Franklin on Scottish music

2003-03-28 Thread Jack Campin
I happened to come across Benjamin Franklin's "Dissertation upon Scottish Music" this week - grandiloquent title for one page of speculations that reads like a Usenet post. I'd expected to find it on the web (e.g. as part of a collected Franklin site) but can't; I might type it in next week if it