Re: [scots-l] Ballad question

2002-12-17 Thread David Kilpatrick
David Francis wrote: David Kilpatrick wrote: maybe the ballads really go back even further to the Bronze Age, and ALL iron is 'metal clear' while those old bronze swords are 'metal broon'... It's an interesting thought, and maybe not so far fetched. Take a look at Alan Garner's essay (he o

Re: [scots-l] Ballad question

2002-12-17 Thread David Francis
David Kilpatrick wrote: >maybe the ballads really go back even further to the > Bronze Age, and ALL iron is 'metal clear' while those old bronze swords > are 'metal broon'... It's an interesting thought, and maybe not so far fetched. Take a look at Alan Garner's essay (he of 'Red Shift', 'The Owl

Re: [scots-l] Ballad question

2002-12-16 Thread Clifford Abrams
David, Thanks very much for your interesting, thorough reply. Yes, there are also a few references to "brown" swords. > 'Metal free' or 'metal clear' refers to the difference between naturally occurring free iron and iron refined from ore ('metal brown') - or to the iron derived from different or

Re: [scots-l] Ballad question

2002-12-15 Thread David Kilpatrick
Clifford Abrams wrote: In many texts, spears or other weapons are often "shod with metal 'free'". Why "free". I understand (from the late Tony Cuffe) that a "wee pen knife" was really very likely a "weapon knife"-- which people were much more likely to carry around in earlier days. (As an aside,