Thank you for your feedback.

The "invisible step" idea is something we borrowed from other list-entry widgets we found in a quick survey of windows applications. I agree it's not the most intuitive thing (and we can certainly improve the implementation as you suggested) but we feel it's convenient once you understand how
it works. If anyone can suggest a better widget, though...

Replay functionality is already (partially) there. If you double-click on a test step, or press Enter when the test step list has the focus, the command is executed right away by Selenium (very easy for us to do since we embed Selenium). Adding a "run" button would be trivial.

Cheers,
--Jonathan

----- Original Message ----- From: "Tres Seaver" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <selenium-devel@lists.public.thoughtworks.org>
Sent: Friday, September 09, 2005 7:04 PM
Subject: [Selenium-devel] Re: test editor


The tool looks very cool.  I have a couple of observations:

 - The "File | New" menu option and equivalent toolbar button didn't
   seem to work:  I couldn't begin recording or adding verbs after
   starting a new test.  When I tried to save the "empty" test, I
   got an oddly-encoded error message (but it did create the file).

   (Later)  It turns out that I was being fooled by the fact that the
   empty first row is not selected, and therefore the editing widgets
   are disabled.  Maybe we should select it immediately after opening
   a file, or creating a new one.

 - "File | New" and "File | Open" don't prompt for changes when the
   "current" test is dirty.

 - The "Suppr" option is probably better "Delete" in English.

 - There is no obvious way to create a new, empty step.

   (Later)  Again, I am fooled by the "invisible" empty step.

 - Could we automatically select the "next" step after the user
   presses <Enter> in an edit widget?

 - Replay functionality would be really cool.

Overall, this looks like an excellent basis for handing test-generation
off to non-programmers.


_______________________________________________
Selenium-devel mailing list
Selenium-devel@lists.public.thoughtworks.org
http://lists.public.thoughtworks.org/mailman/listinfo/selenium-devel

Reply via email to