Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread Harold Solbrig
Dan, Why just integers? It would seem like it would be useful to be able to add provenance (who, when, where...) information to any property - not just integers. President:=Johnson - 1965 or hasChild :: Sarah - 2003 definedIn:=http://w3.org/sample/prelimVersion 2007-08-07 Harold Solbrig

Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread Jeff Thompson
RDF has two ways to handle this. I don't think SMW supports either in a direct way. 1. Blank nodes. Instead of a property having a value of type integer, it has a value of a composite type that has an integer, date, etc. Since it is a "blank node" you don't need to create a unique URI f

Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread S Page
Jeff Thompson wrote: > RDF has two ways to handle this. I don't think SMW supports either in a > direct way. > 1. Blank nodes. Instead of a property having a value of type integer, it has > a value >of a composite type that has an integer, date, etc. Since it is a "blank > node" you >

Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread Yaron Koren
Thanks, S, for finally detailing what n-ary relations will look like in SMW 1.0 - this was an issue of great curiosity to at least a few of us on the mailing list. That said (and I apologize if I'm now hijacking this thread) - are you sure that this is the best way to implement them? The other way

Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread Jeff Thompson
S Page wrote: > I just described SMW 1.0prealpha-3's support for N-ary properties in > response to [Semediawiki-user] Typed links vs. OWL-relations [1], the > same applies here. > > Property:Population_(on_date) would have [[Has type::Integer; Date]] > > The Berlin article would say [[Populatio

Re: [SMW-devel] dated integer type

2007-09-10 Thread S Page
Yaron Koren wrote: > Can you explain the reasoning that went into this [the composite type] > decision? Sorry, no. I'm more an early user of Semantic MediaWiki 1.0pre-alpha3 than a developer. I'm trying it out, filing bugs, and writing docs but AFAIK the development was Deutschland und AIFB