Re: IMAP Fetch behavior on not found messages

2021-01-12 Thread Matthieu Baechler
On Tue, 2021-01-12 at 12:42 +0100, Jean Helou wrote: > > > When doing a fetch with some > non existing messages Cyrus will do a best effort and return the > existing messages whereas James will return a BAD response. I would preserve Cyrus's behavior as a defacto standard, not honoring this

Re: IMAP Fetch behavior on not found messages

2021-01-12 Thread Jean Helou
> > > When doing a fetch with some > non existing messages Cyrus will do a best effort and return the > existing messages whereas James will return a BAD response. I would preserve Cyrus's behavior as a defacto standard, not honoring this incurs the risk of breaking existing client software

Re: IMAP Fetch behavior on not found messages

2021-01-12 Thread Jean Helou
> > The discussion can be found here: > https://github.com/linagora/gatling-imap/pull/3 > actually it's here https://github.com/linagora/gatling-imap/pull/37 I think the url got truncated :)

IMAP Fetch behavior on not found messages

2021-01-12 Thread Raphaƫl Ouazana
|Hi, When adding the support of James on the integration testing of the gatling-imap project, we discovered some discrepancies between the behavior of James and Cyrus on IMAP fetch. When doing a fetch with some non existing messages Cyrus will do a best effort and return the existing messages