Re: [SIESTA-L] forcesToMaster: Etot or free energy?

2021-11-12 Por tôpico Karen Fidanyan
Hi Alberto, thank you for the detailed clarification. I don't know whether there's a universal convention which energy to pass to a socket. I know that FHI-Aims sends the free energy, and that i-PI is designed to be agnostic about the "force codes" it uses. I-PI uses DFT codes as well as force

Re: [SIESTA-L] forcesToMaster: Etot or free energy?

2021-11-10 Por tôpico Alberto Garcia
Hi, Karen, There are several facets in this issue: * When a finite temperature (smearing) is used just for convergence acceleration, the free energy is a computational artifact that is formally needed to restore the variational property. Tests for the size of the smearing and for the fineness