[sig-policy] Re: prop-147-v003: Historical Resources Management

2023-02-05 Thread Owen DeLong via sig-policy
In use != Announced. There are many uses for IP addresses (including legitimate uses of GUA) that don’t make their way into any routing table you can see. Owen > On Jan 26, 2023, at 22:06, Rajesh Panwala wrote: > > Hello Sunny and Team, > > Is there any routing table analysis available,

[sig-policy] Re: New version: prop-150: ROA/whois object with Private,,Reserved and Unallocated (reserved/available) Origin ASN

2023-02-05 Thread Owen DeLong via sig-policy
I think the problem is overstated in that a ROA authorizing origination from an unallocated ASN is not necessarily a security risk. Personally, I don’t see significant benefit to this proposal. I think guidelines are sufficient. People who wish to violate the guidelines, well, to quote Mr.