Re: [Sip-implementors] CANCEL and 2xx(INVITE) race condition

2008-04-09 Thread Paul Kyzivat
It is certainly legal to continue retransmitting the CANCEL even though it will have no effect. A more interesting question is whether it is legal to suppress retransmissions in this case. From a practical perspective I see no problem with doing that if you wish. Paul [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [Sip-implementors] CANCEL and 2xx(INVITE) race condition

2008-04-09 Thread Dale . Worley
From: praveen dandin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Is it valid for UAC to retransmit CANCEL request even after getting 200 OK for INVITE (until UAC receives 200 OK for CANCEL or CANCEL transaction times out)? Yes, of course. It just has no effect. Among other reasons, the UAS has to be prepar

[Sip-implementors] CANCEL and 2xx(INVITE) race condition

2008-04-09 Thread praveen dandin
Hi, Consider the scenario as below: UACUAS | INVITE| |-->| | 180