Re: anonymify a PGP key legally correctly // Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-15 Thread Steffen Kaiser
On 15.06.22 13:42, Gabor Kiss wrote: > On Wed, 15 Jun 2022, Steffen Kaiser wrote: > >> The problem is that the entity processing the data (e.g. stores them) is >> responsible for deletion the possbility to connect the data to a person. >> Actually, I don't know in which way one has to prove the ac

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-15 Thread Tobias Mueller
Hi, On Wed, 2022-06-15 at 06:03 +0200, Kiss Gabor (Bitman) wrote: > And moreover how will I do? You can parse the file with, e.g., sequoia. But you surely knew that you can parse the file, so I wonder what you're trying to convey with your message. Best, Tobi

Re: anonymify a PGP key legally correctly // Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-15 Thread Gabor Kiss
On Wed, 15 Jun 2022, Steffen Kaiser wrote: > The problem is that the entity processing the data (e.g. stores them) is > responsible for deletion the possbility to connect the data to a person. > Actually, I don't know in which way one has to prove the act *legally* > (aka to be accepted in court);

anonymify a PGP key legally correctly // Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-15 Thread Steffen Kaiser
On 15.06.22 06:03, Kiss Gabor (Bitman) wrote: > On Tue, 14 Jun 2022, Jeremy T. Bouse wrote: > >> Am I understanding correctly and you're saying that even with the server >> down he sent the GDPR notice to you? > > The last keydump is available yet. However I can't imagine how > did he find the 16

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-15 Thread Kiss Gabor (Bitman)
On Wed, 15 Jun 2022, Tobias Mueller wrote: > > And moreover how will I do? > You can parse the file with, e.g., sequoia. Thanks. Unfortunately the keydump is kept on an old Debian machine. I'm not sure I can install sequoia there. I have to search alternate solutions too. > But you surely knew t

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Kiss Gabor (Bitman)
On Tue, 14 Jun 2022, Jeremy T. Bouse wrote: > Am I understanding correctly and you're saying that even with the server > down he sent the GDPR notice to you? The last keydump is available yet. However I can't imagine how did he find the 16 keys in the 12 GiB compressed binary mess-up. And moreove

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Jeremy T. Bouse
Gabor, Am I understanding correctly and you're saying that even with the server down he sent the GDPR notice to you? I'll laugh if I suddenly receive one for my previous SKS server that ran and has been offline for several years now. Being a non-EU operator I'd be inclined to say pound sand. On

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Gabor Kiss
On Tue, 14 Jun 2022, I?aki Arenaza wrote: > willingness to prove it), he could also use a digital certificate system > that is operated by the government and legally binding in my > country[1][2] (both of us are Spanish citizens). > > And at my request, he has digitally signed a document -produc

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread IƱaki Arenaza
On mar, jun 14 2022, Gabor Kiss wrote: > On Tue, 14 Jun 2022, Klaus-Uwe (Kumi) Mitterer wrote: > >> Just my personal legal opinion, but I don't think that they are required to >> actually control those keys, only to demonstrate that they are the person >> whose personal data is included the keys'

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Gabor Kiss
On Tue, 14 Jun 2022, Klaus-Uwe (Kumi) Mitterer wrote: > Just my personal legal opinion, but I don't think that they are required to > actually control those keys, only to demonstrate that they are the person > whose personal data is included the keys' user IDs. Google gives several hits for "Luis

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Klaus-Uwe (Kumi) Mitterer
Hi all, Just my personal legal opinion, but I don't think that they are required to actually control those keys, only to demonstrate that they are the person whose personal data is included the keys' user IDs. Just imagine if *I* uploaded a key with a user ID containing *your* name, street a

Re: ... GDPR takedown request

2022-06-14 Thread Kiss Gabor (Bitman)
> > IMHO Mr. Puerto must show some evidence first about the key to delete > > belongs to him. Otherwise any impostor can make delete other guys' > > key. > > I thought the same thing and asked him (privately) to resend his request > in a PGP-signed email, which he did, so this is legit. Gee. I'm