[slurm-dev] Re: On the need for slurm uid/gid consistency

2017-09-13 Thread Douglas Jacobsen
I would suggest it is a more general requirement, not simply enforced by use of munge, which does imply a unified uid trust level across all nodes using the same preshared key, but also when jobs are started, they are started with a particular uid and other credentials (transmitted in the slurm

[slurm-dev] Re: On the need for slurm uid/gid consistency

2017-09-13 Thread Christopher Samuel
On 13/09/17 04:53, Phil K wrote: > I'm hoping someone can provide an explanation as to why slurm > requires uid/gid consistency across nodes, with emphasis on the need > for the 'SlurmUser' to be uid/gid-consistent. I think this is a consequence of the use of Munge, rather than being inherent

[slurm-dev] Re: On the need for slurm uid/gid consistency

2017-09-13 Thread Philip Kovacs
I'm not trying to solve any problems, I'm just trying to understand the issue well enough so that I can make informed decisions as a downstream package maintainer.  With the need for uid/gid consistency, we either need to pass on the issue, i.e. package for use by root, or we need to do

[slurm-dev] Re: On the need for slurm uid/gid consistency

2017-09-13 Thread Janne Blomqvist
On 2017-09-12 21:52, Phil K wrote: I'm hoping someone can provide an explanation as to why slurm requires uid/gid consistency across nodes, with emphasis on the need for the 'SlurmUser' to be uid/gid-consistent. I know that slurmctld and slurmdbd can run as user `slurm` and that this would be