Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-24 Thread Webster Homer
I don't like that this behavior is not documented. It appears from this that aliases are recursive (sort of) and that isn't documented. On Wed, Jan 24, 2018 at 6:38 AM, alessandro.benedetti wrote: > b2b-catalog-material-etl -> b2b-catalog-material > b2b-catalog-material -> b2b-catalog-material-1

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-24 Thread alessandro.benedetti
b2b-catalog-material-etl -> b2b-catalog-material b2b-catalog-material -> b2b-catalog-material-180117 and we do a data load to b2b-catalog-material-etl We see data being added to both b2b-catalog-material and b2b-catalog-material-180117 -> *in here you wanted just to index in b2b-catalog-mate

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-23 Thread Webster Homer
Thanks, Erick. The main reason that we assigned the alias this way was for consistency. The consistency of communicating with the administrators that actually maintain the solr instances in our QA and production clouds. They know very little about solr. It was useful to have all the interfaces in p

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-20 Thread Erick Erickson
SOLR-11488 is there so we formalize what we intend here. For instance, at one point we discovered that you could have an alias pointing to collection1,collection2 then delete collection2 say. Solr was happy in that configuration but it made no sense. See SOLR-11218. So I don't know what the eventu

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-19 Thread Webster Homer
It seems like a useful feature, especially for migrating from standalone to solrcloud, at least if the precedence of alias to collection is defined and enforced. On Fri, Jan 19, 2018 at 5:01 PM, Shawn Heisey wrote: > On 1/19/2018 3:53 PM, Webster Homer wrote: > >> I created the alias with an exi

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-19 Thread Shawn Heisey
On 1/19/2018 3:53 PM, Webster Homer wrote: I created the alias with an existing collection name because our code base which was created with stand alone solr was a pain to change. I did test that the alias took precedence over the collection, when I did a search. The ability to create aliases a

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-19 Thread Webster Homer
I created the alias with an existing collection name because our code base which was created with stand alone solr was a pain to change. I did test that the alias took precedence over the collection, when I did a search. On Fri, Jan 19, 2018 at 4:22 PM, Wenjie Zhang (Jack) < wenjiezhang2...@gmail.

Re: Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-19 Thread Wenjie Zhang (Jack)
Why would you create an alias with an existing collection name? Sent from my iPhone > On Jan 19, 2018, at 14:14, Webster Homer wrote: > > I just discovered some odd behavior with aliases. > > We are in the process of converting over to use aliases in solrcloud. We > have a number of collection

Strange Alias behavior

2018-01-19 Thread Webster Homer
I just discovered some odd behavior with aliases. We are in the process of converting over to use aliases in solrcloud. We have a number of collections that applications have referenced the collections from when we used standalone solr. So we created alias names to match the name that the java app