Re: Please Help !! Question about Query Phrase Slop (qs) in dismax
: Subject: Re: Please Help !! Question about Query Phrase Slop (qs) in dismax : : : Please help someone...i've been waiting for an answer for the last couple of : days no one seems to be helping out here. I did search the wiki this Please don't send messages like this. This is a volunteer community -- no one (that I know of) is paid to read/reply to questions on the solr-user list. Many of us do our best to make sure that all user questions get addressed, but this is a fairly high volume list, and sometimes other things in life (work, health, relationships, family, etc...) make that take a little longer then we would like -- sometimes questions don't get answered for a few days, it's just the way it is, please be patient. Sending multiple please help, still no reply type messages just adds noise to the list, and give people who *do* want to help more to read which means it takes that much longer to actually reply. If you need an answer to a question in a hurry: read the archives and the docs, experiment, read the code (if you know java), or hire a consultant to help you figure it out. In this specific case, debugQuery=true would have quickly shown you that your qs=5 value wasn't making it's way into the parsedquery at all, which might have helped you understand what was happening. -Hoss
Re: Please Help !! Question about Query Phrase Slop (qs) in dismax
Thanks for the response. Well my current ps setting works great for most search terms. But say this typical example, north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers - we don't have any relevant docs in the index. Solr is returning the irrelevant doc, just because it found 'lawyer', exchange, north dakota somewhere. I thought if there is a way to just not return any results if they are not within close proximity, it would be great. Yonik Seeley wrote: On Sun, Nov 23, 2008 at 11:51 PM, anuvenk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Please help someone...i've been waiting for an answer for the last couple of days no one seems to be helping out here. I did search the wiki this forum for an answer. But couldn't find an answer. I know if ps is set to 5 words within 5 words of one another receive a boost in score. But is there a way to not return results that have the words in search terms more than 5 words apart. ? Not with dismax. I'm not sure why it's a problem, given that with enough boost you should be able to ensure that all of the results with a slop less than 5 appear before other results. Anyway, if you want to restrict results to those with a slop of 5, use the standard query parser with an explicit sloppy phrase query: north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers~5 -Yonik Typical example: north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers My first result is absolutely ir-relevant. It returned a north dakota doc though but had an occurrence of attorney somewhere an occurrence of exchange (not related to 1031 exchange though). They were not within 5 words of one another. My guys have been hammering me reg this relevancy issue. Please help someone. anuvenk wrote: From the solr wiki, it sounded like if qs is set to 5 for example, if the search term is 'child custody', only docs with 'child' 'custody' within 5 words of one another would be returned in results. Is this correct? If so, it doesn't seem to be working for me. I see docs with 'child' 'custody' more than 5 words of one another (excluding stop words) which is resulting in bad user experience as those docs are not so relevant. What more could i do to improve quality in the results? -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Please-Help-%21%21-Question-about-Query-Phrase-Slop-%28qs%29-in-dismax-tp20643003p20654906.html Sent from the Solr - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com. -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Please-Help-%21%21-Question-about-Query-Phrase-Slop-%28qs%29-in-dismax-tp20643003p20655014.html Sent from the Solr - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
Re: Please Help !! Question about Query Phrase Slop (qs) in dismax
If you boost the phrase queries by enough, you could tell when you hit the less relevant documents by the score. -Yonik On Mon, Nov 24, 2008 at 12:07 AM, anuvenk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thanks for the response. Well my current ps setting works great for most search terms. But say this typical example, north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers - we don't have any relevant docs in the index. Solr is returning the irrelevant doc, just because it found 'lawyer', exchange, north dakota somewhere. I thought if there is a way to just not return any results if they are not within close proximity, it would be great. Yonik Seeley wrote: On Sun, Nov 23, 2008 at 11:51 PM, anuvenk [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Please help someone...i've been waiting for an answer for the last couple of days no one seems to be helping out here. I did search the wiki this forum for an answer. But couldn't find an answer. I know if ps is set to 5 words within 5 words of one another receive a boost in score. But is there a way to not return results that have the words in search terms more than 5 words apart. ? Not with dismax. I'm not sure why it's a problem, given that with enough boost you should be able to ensure that all of the results with a slop less than 5 appear before other results. Anyway, if you want to restrict results to those with a slop of 5, use the standard query parser with an explicit sloppy phrase query: north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers~5 -Yonik Typical example: north dakota 1031 exchange lawyers My first result is absolutely ir-relevant. It returned a north dakota doc though but had an occurrence of attorney somewhere an occurrence of exchange (not related to 1031 exchange though). They were not within 5 words of one another. My guys have been hammering me reg this relevancy issue. Please help someone. anuvenk wrote: From the solr wiki, it sounded like if qs is set to 5 for example, if the search term is 'child custody', only docs with 'child' 'custody' within 5 words of one another would be returned in results. Is this correct? If so, it doesn't seem to be working for me. I see docs with 'child' 'custody' more than 5 words of one another (excluding stop words) which is resulting in bad user experience as those docs are not so relevant. What more could i do to improve quality in the results? -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Please-Help-%21%21-Question-about-Query-Phrase-Slop-%28qs%29-in-dismax-tp20643003p20654906.html Sent from the Solr - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com. -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Please-Help-%21%21-Question-about-Query-Phrase-Slop-%28qs%29-in-dismax-tp20643003p20655014.html Sent from the Solr - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
