Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-07 Thread Richard Fontana
On Fri, Nov 30, 2018 at 07:20:15PM -0500, Michael Dolan wrote: > The Common Cure Rights Commitment (CCRC) which was based on the KES also > applies to an indefinite pool of projects. If one or a few of the companies > own all the copyright, my recommendation would be to just relicense the >

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-03 Thread James Bottomley
On Mon, 2018-12-03 at 10:34 -0500, Michael Dolan wrote: > So if I can summarize my the situation we're discussing: > > 1) The additional permission is from one or more of many authors and > would only apply in a situation where that author(s)' code is being > enforced as part of a work. Yes. As

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-03 Thread Michael Dolan
So if I can summarize my the situation we're discussing: 1) The additional permission is from one or more of many authors and would only apply in a situation where that author(s)' code is being enforced as part of a work. 2) The license for the file, any resultant binary or the work would not

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-01 Thread James Bottomley
On Sat, 2018-12-01 at 14:36 -0500, Michael Dolan wrote: > James thanks for that explanation it helps me understand the angle > you're thinking of using this for much better. > > Let me ask one follow-up if I may. Is it broadly the intention to > change the license for new files in the kernel

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-01 Thread Michael Dolan
James thanks for that explanation it helps me understand the angle you're thinking of using this for much better. Let me ask one follow-up if I may. Is it broadly the intention to change the license for new files in the kernel going forward to require the KES? I haven't had a conversation like

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-12-01 Thread James Bottomley
On Fri, 2018-11-30 at 19:20 -0500, Michael Dolan wrote: > I'm just catching up late on a Friday night and noticed this. I have > to say I'm surprised this suddenly went to last call for comments. I > guess I missed the prior discussion on the list about this and > apologize for showing up late. >

Plan to add Linux Kernel Enforcement Statement to SPDX additional permissions list (Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment)

2018-11-30 Thread Bradley M. Kuhn
Michael Dolan wrote: > It solely modifies an individual's contribution with additional > permissions. Indeed, that's precisely what every "additional permission" does (going back to the Bison Exception in the 1980s). So, you've basically stated there the very definition of a "license

Re: meeting minutes: Linux kernel enforcement statement / GPL Cooperation Commitment

2018-11-30 Thread Michael Dolan
I'm just catching up late on a Friday night and noticed this. I have to say I'm surprised this suddenly went to last call for comments. I guess I missed the prior discussion on the list about this and apologize for showing up late. I honestly do not understand the rationale for doing this. When