Re: some questions on OpenID AX 1.0 draft 4

2007-04-08 Thread Dick Hardt
Hi Mark, for some reason I just saw this post, answers and questions inserted ... On 5-Apr-07, at 9:47 AM, Mark Wahl wrote: > > http://openid.net/specs/openid-attribute-exchange-1_0-04.html > > 1. Section 2 states that the store operation "saves or updates > attribute information on the OpenID

Re: PROPOSAL schema.openid.net for AX (and other extensions)

2007-04-08 Thread Dick Hardt
Hi Mark The URL mapping of LDAP attributes below looks pretty useful. Some of those overlap with attributes we defined for AX, but many of the attributes in AX are not defined, or don't have the same granularity. Given that LDAP attributes were defined per the needs of enterprise, and AX at

Re: Promoting OpenID

2007-04-08 Thread Dick Hardt
On 5-Apr-07, at 8:46 PM, Johannes Ernst wrote: > On Apr 5, 2007, at 18:36, Chris Messina wrote: > >> ... I personally think selling to the enterprise is nearly >> impossible without tons of grassroots adoption ... > > I disagree. ;-) > > Now granted, there are many, many things that we all need t

Re: PROPOSAL schema.openid.net for AX (and other extensions)

2007-04-08 Thread Mark Wahl
Dick Hardt wrote: > If there was something out there already, I would propose we used it. > There is not. > > Just like the SAML crowd has accused the OpenID crowd of reinventing an > identity protocol (AKA reinventing the wheel) -- the AX proposal has > some unique concepts that people lik

Re: Web Access Management

2007-04-08 Thread Dick Hardt
Tony Nadalin from IBM and Dale Olds from Novell are well aware of what is happening in OpenID. The lack of a clear IPR policy is preventing Microsoft from directly participating in the mailing lists. A number of us met at Microsoft [1] and this was one of the issues that we are working to add

Re: SREG namespace URI rollback

2007-04-08 Thread Recordon, David
I'm fine with keeping it 1.0 as Josh proposed. --David -Original Message- From: Johnny Bufu [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, April 07, 2007 09:38 PM Pacific Standard Time To: Recordon, David Cc: Josh Hoyt; OpenID specs list Subject:Re: SREG namespace URI rol