RE: Map/Normalize Email Address to IdP/OP URL (Was [PROPOSAL] Handlehttp://[EMAIL PROTECTED] Style Identifiers)

2006-11-13 Thread Recordon, David
I'm not sure if it would necessarily be thrown away, I guess it is really up to the IdP. With two identifiers, it is pretty easy to pass to the IdP and let it decide what it wants to do. 1) I enter [EMAIL PROTECTED] as my identifier on the RP 2) RP does discovery on recordon.name and finds my

RE: OpenID Auth 2.0 and user-agent neutrality (or, OpenID with REST/SOAP)

2006-11-13 Thread Recordon, David
Hey Adam, Thanks for the insight! I know, as Dick described, there was a design decision made in terms of enabling payloads larger than 2Kb within OpenID Authentication requests and responses. With that said, there are other approaches, such as using GET requests and including a token to

RE: Went Through it With Brad

2006-11-13 Thread Recordon, David
Solution 1 seems like the most simple. openid2 is a bit ugly, but does resolve the problem. Otherwise we'd have to do something like Yadis discovery against the server endpoint which would make things more complicated and meta. --David -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Went Through it With Brad

2006-11-13 Thread Johannes Ernst
The problem with that proposal is that the maintenance of the HTML file and the maintenance of the server version is performed by different people, and that means it is impossible that they are consistent ;-) What about adding a version parameter to each response from the endpoint? On