OpenID 2.0 Section 9.2.1

2007-10-29 Thread John Ehn
I've been reviewing Draft 12, and noticed this section, which I think will cause problems for some systems. 9.2.1. Using the Realm for Return URL Verification OpenID providers SHOULD verify that the return_to URL specified in the request is an OpenID relying party endpoint. To verify a

Re: OpenID 2.0 Section 9.2.1

2007-10-29 Thread James Henstridge
On 29/10/2007, John Ehn [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've been reviewing Draft 12, and noticed this section, which I think will cause problems for some systems. 9.2.1. Using the Realm for Return URL Verification OpenID providers SHOULD verify that the return_to URL specified in the request is

Re: OpenID 2.0 Section 9.2.1

2007-10-29 Thread John Ehn
Okay. Can we re-word it then so it's more explicitly stated? I.E.: Attempt discovery. If discovery succeeds, ensure return_to URL is specified in the XRDS document. If not present, always return negative assertion. If discovery fails, assume return_to URL is valid and return assertion.