Re: Re[2]: [PROPOSAL] request nonce and name

2006-10-16 Thread Grant Monroe
On 10/14/06, Dick Hardt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Also note that URL parameters are not secured by TLS in HTTPS.

 -- Dick
URL parameters are sent with the path in the GET line of the HTTP
request after the TLS handshake, so URL parameters ARE secured.

-- 
 Grant Monroe
 JanRain, Inc.
___
specs mailing list
specs@openid.net
http://openid.net/mailman/listinfo/specs


Re: Re[2]: [PROPOSAL] request nonce and name

2006-10-14 Thread Dick Hardt
Also note that URL parameters are not secured by TLS in HTTPS.

-- Dick

On 13-Oct-06, at 3:57 AM, Chris Drake wrote:

 Hi All,

 Just so everyone remembers:  GET encoded http://; URLs usually
 appear en-mass in public lists (from proxy cache logs).  If you don't
 want to POST data anyplace, remember to expect replay attacks
 often.

 Kind Regards,
 Chris Drake


 Friday, October 13, 2006, 7:48:31 PM, you wrote:

 JH On 10/13/06, Martin Atkins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 True, even one single pass through parameter should do.

 This causes the minor inconvenience that the RP will probably now  
 have
 to implement its own parsing, rather than using the framework's
 pre-supplied functions for dealing with urlencoded query strings.

 Not a major deal, but I'd guess that this is where the idea to use
 return_to args came from in the first place.

 JH return_to arguments can only be trusted if they are taken from the
 JH signed return_to parameter, which means parsing the signed  
 return_to
 JH parameter anyway. So it's at least no worse.

 JH It's better in that the parameters do not now appear twice in the
 JH response (once double-encoded)

 JH Example of a response with parameter in the return_to:

 JH http://a.url/?drink=0xC0FFEE%21openid.return_to=http%3A//a.url/ 
 %3Fdrink%3D0xC0FFEE%2521...

 JH Example of a response with hypothetical openid.appdata field:

 JH http://a.url/?openid.appdata=drink%3D0xC0FFEE% 
 21openid.return_to=http%3A//a.url/...

 JH Josh
 JH ___
 JH specs mailing list
 JH specs@openid.net
 JH http://openid.net/mailman/listinfo/specs



 ___
 specs mailing list
 specs@openid.net
 http://openid.net/mailman/listinfo/specs



___
specs mailing list
specs@openid.net
http://openid.net/mailman/listinfo/specs