RE: Excessive system pressure

2009-03-19 Thread John Drucker
Thermal Expansion Water Hammer One of the consequences of installing a backflow prevention assembly on any water system is the system becoming a closed system. A closed system is a system, which is not open to the atmosphere. A pressurized tank would be a closed system, since there is no means

Emergency Vents on Small Diesel Fuel Tanks

2009-03-19 Thread Fletcher, Ron
Now our local AHJ is requiring emergency vents on UL 142 diesel fuel tanks be vented to outside. And because we will be adding pipe and fittings between the tank and the vent they want calculations to prove that the pipe size is adequate and the vent will operate as advertised. (It seems like only

RE: Excessive system pressure

2009-03-19 Thread Dave Sornsin
Rodney: Just curious. I'm guessing there's gotta be a few dry systems down there in unheated warehouses with extreme temp swings. So in these systems with 100% air, do you find the pressure above the dry valves climbing to extreme levels in the summer? Dave Sornsin General Manager - Fargo Office

RE: Excessive system pressure

2009-03-19 Thread Chris Cahill
I find it VERY interesting that you find it VERY interesting there has been no findings. Hint of insecurity in your position? Why would anyone try your experiment when it is irrelevant to the constant volume container of a sprinkler system? No one believes water compression is responsible for

Re: Emergency Vents on Small Diesel Fuel Tanks

2009-03-19 Thread Ron Greenman
Ron, Note that your problem is similar to the one posted a couple of weeks ago about sprinklers and limited combustible construction in concealed spaces. The AHJ in that case did not follow the line of reason/interpretation to its conclusion. Instead the AHJ stopped with chapter X (I can't

Re: Excessive system pressure

2009-03-19 Thread Ron Greenman
Thanks John. I knew there was a missing component in that experiment but couldn't (read wasn't interested enough) to put my finger on it. Thermal expansion--makes you go Hm? On Thu, Mar 19, 2009 at 4:20 AM, John Drucker john.druc...@verizon.net wrote: Thermal Expansion Water Hammer One of

RE: Test/Drain at the Riser

2009-03-19 Thread Todd Williams
Water does expand and contract (Think ice bursting pipes) with temperature. It is called thermal expansion. The coefficient of expansion is not linear and varies with temperature. In the normal range of temperatures that a system would be in (non-fire), the coefficient is very small, but could

Re: Excessive system pressure

2009-03-19 Thread Roland Huggins
There are times when folks just have to agree to disagree. I asked nicely last week to do just that and let this thread die. We all enjoy a good debate but not when it becomes unnecessary contentious Just because no one else agrees with your position is not a valid reason to say that

RE: Test/Drain at the Riser

2009-03-19 Thread rahe . loftin
I haven't kept up with this thread, but I was just wondering if the gauge used is an air/water gauge that will measure air pressure as well as water pressure. You can get these extremes with air compressed by expanded water. Thank You Rahe Loftin, P.E. Region 7 - GSA Office - 817-978-7299 Fax -

Fire Protection System for Cleanroom and NMR

2009-03-19 Thread Haji, Jaber M
Your insights/opinions of the best/most popular fixed fire protection system for a cleanroom and NMR in an advanced research laboratory facilities. Jaber M. Al-Haji jaber.h...@aramco.com jaber.h...@kaust.edu.sa The contents of this email, including all related responses, files and attachments

RE: Seismic - NFA 13 vs IBC

2009-03-19 Thread R Richardson
Even with the new language in the supplement as referenced by Steve, the issue is not clear. The language in the supplement indicates that NFPA 13 is essentially equivalent to section 13.6.8 of ASCE. However, the requirement for 2 in. oversized rings is not in section 13.6.8. It is in

Re: Fire Protection System for Cleanroom and NMR

2009-03-19 Thread tgw
For clean rooms, I have mostly done pre-action systems with clean room sprinklers. NMR (non magnetic room?), similar to MRI spaces? Cpvc pipe and non-ferrous sprinklers and appurtenances. Most of the ones have been pre-action, but could also be wet. --Original Message-- From: Haji,

Re: Seismic - NFA 13 vs IBC

2009-03-19 Thread ParsleyConsulting
Rich, I think the supplement provides a great deal of clarification, if what Joe Powell's question dealt with was Does the IBC allow NFPA-13 criteria to be used for seismic protection. I understand your reference regarding the oversize rings, but I think it's relevant to note that the

RE: Seismic - NFA 13 vs. IBC

2009-03-19 Thread Jeff Hewitt
Ken, I disagree. The requirements for the 2-in. clearance is to prevent damage to the sprinkler or drop due to excessive movement of the piping, not the due to movement of the ceiling. If the ceiling is held to a more strenuous standard making it more rigid, that will not remove the requirement

RE: Seismic - NFA 13 vs. IBC

2009-03-19 Thread Craig.Prahl
Speaking of seismic, how many have had to adhere to the Special Inspection provisions and other requirements in IBC 2006? I'm getting various input from only having to use the work sheet provided in 13 for calcs all the way up to having to have a Structural PE design the braces, provide

Re: Seismic - NFA 13 vs. IBC

2009-03-19 Thread ParsleyConsulting
Jeff, I disagree with your disagreement, sort of. In item (e) from the ASCE7 section we're discussing on the ceiling rings, it explicitly notes that a swing joint which will accommodate 1 of ceiling movement in all directions waives the requirement for the oversize ring. I do agree that the

RE: Fire Pump relief valve discharge

2009-03-19 Thread A.P.Silva
The building owner wants to connect the discharge piping from the pump relief valve to the pump suction pipe, just upstream of the suction valve. The water supply to the pump is a water storage tank. Anyone seen this arrangement? Is it acceptable? NFPA 20, 2007 section 5.18.7 mentions Discharge