Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-08 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Mon, 7 May 2018, Warren Young wrote: On May 7, 2018, at 9:53 AM, Philip Bennefall wrote: It was merely an idea to possibly avoid some potential ambiguity regarding public domain, which is a bit of a gray area in many places. So take the code under the explicit

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Philip Bennefall
I am far from an expert in this field myself so I don't know whether including it in the text section of the binary would be enough, and the main issue for me is when clients of mine redistribute middleware in their turn as I mentioned in an earlier post. But either way, Richard already

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Warren Young
On May 7, 2018, at 9:53 AM, Philip Bennefall wrote: > > It was merely an idea to possibly avoid some potential ambiguity regarding > public domain, which is a bit of a gray area in many places. So take the code under the explicit license, then. In my non-expert opinion,

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread R Smith
On 2018/05/07 5:53 PM, Philip Bennefall wrote: It was merely an idea to possibly avoid some potential ambiguity regarding public domain, which is a bit of a gray area in many places. Obviously not a requirement for anyone to do anything, it was but a friendly question. All good sir, the jibe

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Philip Bennefall
It was merely an idea to possibly avoid some potential ambiguity regarding public domain, which is a bit of a gray area in many places. Obviously not a requirement for anyone to do anything, it was but a friendly question. Kind regards, Philip On 5/7/2018 5:44 PM, R Smith wrote: On

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread R Smith
On 2018/05/07 5:33 PM, Philip Bennefall wrote: Thanks very much for that information, Richard! :) I don't know if it would make any difference legally, but perhaps this could be made explicit in the comments? So it's not enough to get it free... the free giver has to now put some extra

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Philip Bennefall
Thanks very much for that information, Richard! :) I don't know if it would make any difference legally, but perhaps this could be made explicit in the comments? Thanks again. Kind regards, Philip On 5/7/2018 5:22 PM, Richard Hipp wrote: You are welcomed to use the public-domain version of

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Richard Hipp
You are welcomed to use the public-domain version of the delta encoding routines found in the SQLite source tree for whatever purpose you want, without attribution. I am the sole author of that code, and I am a citizen of a country that allows people to disavow intellectual property claims, so it

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Philip Bennefall
As far as I can judge, you need to include the entire license - or at least the majority of it - in the documentation (not just a single line). For an end user product that's fine, but I would rather not have to ask clients to do so if I am distributing middleware simply because of a component

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-07 Thread Peter Da Silva
On 5/6/18, 11:23 AM, "sqlite-users on behalf of Philip Bennefall" wrote: Only the requirement for attribution in binaries. That can be significant in certain use cases. One line of text in the documentation

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-06 Thread Philip Bennefall
Only the requirement for attribution in binaries. That can be significant in certain use cases. Kind regards, Philip Bennefall On 5/6/2018 6:19 PM, Richard Hipp wrote: On 5/6/18, Philip Bennefall wrote: Hi all, I had a quick question regarding the licensing of the

Re: [sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-06 Thread Richard Hipp
On 5/6/18, Philip Bennefall wrote: > Hi all, > > > I had a quick question regarding the licensing of the delta compression > code found in the sqldiff and the RBU extensions for SqLite. I see that > this code is extracted from Fossil, which is under the BSD license. But > the

[sqlite] Fossil Delta Compression in SqLite

2018-05-06 Thread Philip Bennefall
Hi all, I had a quick question regarding the licensing of the delta compression code found in the sqldiff and the RBU extensions for SqLite. I see that this code is extracted from Fossil, which is under the BSD license. But the header of the source files in the SqLite repository which