Re: [Standards] Form for Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Sam Whited
I don't think it matters so much where the compliance suites live or what process we use to edit them. An XEP seems fine, but so does a page on the website and we just say "and the council has to approve changes". The only difference that I see is who hits the publish button: the website people or

Re: [Standards] Form for Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Dave Cridland
On Fri, 4 Sep 2020 at 13:51, Andrew Nenakhov < andrew.nenak...@redsolution.com> wrote: > пт, 4 сент. 2020 г. в 16:37, Georg Lukas : > > > This was discussed before, and in my eyes the XEP hammer looks > > sufficiently right for this, as it gives us: > > > > - a proper process to decide what goes i

Re: [Standards] Form for Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Andrew Nenakhov
пт, 4 сент. 2020 г. в 16:37, Georg Lukas : > This was discussed before, and in my eyes the XEP hammer looks > sufficiently right for this, as it gives us: > > - a proper process to decide what goes into the Compliance Suite In efficient organizations a process serves as means to some end. But thi

[Standards] Form for Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Georg Lukas
Hi Andrew, thanks for your suggestion! * Andrew Nenakhov [2020-09-04 11:08]: > I understand that boy with a hammer treats everything as a nail, but > come on: if you really want a compliance suite, you shouldn't pollute > the list of extensions with this day-to-day bureaucracy, but simply > publ

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Florian Schmaus
On 9/4/20 11:06 AM, Andrew Nenakhov wrote: > […] if you really > want a compliance suite, you shouldn't pollute the list of extensions > with this day-to-day bureaucracy, but simply publish a 'compliance > suite' page on https://xmpp.org/compliance/ URL and update it when > necessary. You get persi

Re: [Standards] Very Simple Questions about Compliance Suites

2020-09-04 Thread Andrew Nenakhov
We don't really care. In part, because we have implemented far too many extensions that are necessary to provide speedy work on iOS/web platforms, some of which outright replace the ones listed in those suites, and, in part, because the XEPs are lately grossly misused by the XSF, being used now for