Re: s6-rc: timeout questions

2020-11-20 Thread Xavier Stonestreet
Thanks for taking the time to respond and for all your detailed answers, much appreciated. On Wed, Nov 18, 2020 at 8:06 PM Laurent Bercot wrote: [...]

Re: s6-rc: timeout questions

2020-11-18 Thread Laurent Bercot
Could you elaborate a little more about the state transition failures of oneshots caused by timeouts? Let's say for example the oneshot's up script times out, so the transition fails. From s6-rc's point of view the oneshot is still down. What actually happens to the process running the up

Re: s6-rc: timeout questions

2020-11-18 Thread Xavier Stonestreet
Thank you for your clarifications. > And then, of course, the point is that it's needed for oneshots, > which do not have the s6 mechanisms. Right. Understood. > >- Can you confirm that timeout-up and timeout-down are also used with > >oneshots? They are defined in the s6-rc-compile

Re: s6-rc: timeout questions

2020-11-17 Thread Laurent Bercot
- Am I correct in thinking that if a service has properly configured timeout-kill and timeout-finish, timeout-down becomes unnecessary and even undesirable as it can leave services in an undefined state limbo? I know the documentation pretty much says so, but I'm still a bit confused by the

s6-rc: timeout questions

2020-11-17 Thread Xavier Stonestreet
Hello, - Am I correct in thinking that if a service has properly configured timeout-kill and timeout-finish, timeout-down becomes unnecessary and even undesirable as it can leave services in an undefined state limbo? I know the documentation pretty much says so, but I'm still a bit confused by