[pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Bruce B
Hi Everyone, I am facing a dilemma here. If I port forward 1-2 to my first Asterisk server which sets behind pfSense v1.2.3 then I have two way audio. If I remove it I don't have any audio but call establishes. Now, I have a second server, so I am stuck with what to do on the NAT. I

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Jesse Vollmar
On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 1:55 PM, Bruce B bruceb...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Everyone, I am facing a dilemma here. If I port forward 1-2 to my first Asterisk server which sets behind pfSense v1.2.3 then I have two way audio. If I remove it I don't have any audio but call establishes.

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread David Burgess
On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 11:55 AM, Bruce B bruceb...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Everyone, I am facing a dilemma here. If I port forward 1-2 to my first Asterisk server which sets behind pfSense v1.2.3 then I have two way audio. If I remove it I don't have any audio but call establishes. Now,

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Chris Buechler
On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 3:34 PM, David Burgess apt@gmail.com wrote: On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 11:55 AM, Bruce B bruceb...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Everyone, I am facing a dilemma here. If I port forward 1-2 to my first Asterisk server which sets behind pfSense v1.2.3 then I have two way

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Jason C. Taylor
I have not worked with Asterisk or SIP at all, but it sounds like what you need is a combination of sipproxd to get past the NAT issues and some sort of load balancer like SER or Ultra Monkey to round-robin (or whatever) the two Asterisk servers. So that you'd wind up with: asterisk1 -*

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Francois-Alexandre St-Onge Aubut
doing that SIP will broke On 11-01-14 04:18 PM, Jason C. Taylor wrote: I have not worked with Asterisk or SIP at all, but it sounds like what you need is a combination of sipproxd to get past the NAT issues and some sort of load balancer like SER or Ultra Monkey to round-robin (or whatever)

Re: [pfSense Support] Is it possible to Port Forward same PORT to TWO servers? pfsense + TWO Asterisk servers and NAT

2011-01-14 Thread Bruce B
Simple solution is to limit the RTP port start and end in each Asterisk server and use those ports with NON STATIC port setup in outbound NAT and all should be fine. Thanks for the suggestions. On Fri, Jan 14, 2011 at 4:21 PM, Francois-Alexandre St-Onge Aubut fst-o...@idsmicronet.com wrote: