[symfony-devs] Re: duplicate plugin code

2007-12-19 Thread Jonathan Wage
I think it is a lot of work to have to maintain a plugin for multiple ORM's. It would be nice, but I don't think it is realistic. You should spend a few hours porting sfGuardDoctrinePlugin functionality to sfGuardPlugin as a new branch/version of the plugin. - Jon On Dec 13, 2007 8:31 AM, Ian P.

[symfony-devs] Re: duplicate plugin code

2007-12-13 Thread Ian P. Christian
gimler wrote: > yes but we can rewrite the plugins step by step so i would rewrite the > sfGuard ;) > > for few days a user on the mailing list has the problem that he miss > some functions in sfGuardPlugin that has sfGuardDoctrinePlugin Well, if an API is drawn up and decided for sfGuard, it s

[symfony-devs] Re: duplicate plugin code

2007-12-13 Thread gimler
yes but we can rewrite the plugins step by step so i would rewrite the sfGuard ;) for few days a user on the mailing list has the problem that he miss some functions in sfGuardPlugin that has sfGuardDoctrinePlugin my problem is descipted in this ticket: http://trac.symfony-project.com/ticket/266

[symfony-devs] Re: duplicate plugin code

2007-12-13 Thread Ian P. Christian
gimler wrote: > what do you think? > have anybody another idea? > Conceptually, a fantastic idea. It kinda results in abstracting the abstraction, but in this case, I don't think it'sa bad idea. Finding people with the time to refactor all these plugins would be the main issue I imagine. -