Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-04 Thread Brad Neuhauser
Doug, Since you're pretty knowledgable about this topic, it'd probably also be good if you could flesh out the harbor:LOCODE page on the wiki ( http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:harbour:LOCODE). It's part of this big harbour proposal: wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Harbour

Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-04 Thread Malcolm Herring
On 04/02/2013 18:26, Douglas Fraser wrote: The data management issues are important, so I'm inclined to update the wiki page to direct people to OpenSeamap as that seems like a more logical place to keep specialized metadata like this and they'd be more inclined to keep the data updated.

Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-04 Thread Douglas Fraser
well, I'd like to contribute but I don't want to stomp all over already done work - we have a fairly complete and authoritative set of LOCODEs, including the shipping carrier specific ones (shipping companies feel free to make up their own set of LOCODEs sometimes) so the big question is where

Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-04 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2013/2/4 Douglas Fraser doug.fra...@tarisoga.com: as for LOCODE and locode, it is an acronym and so I tend to capitalize it. but if iata isn't... There are LOCODE / locode / harbour:locode / unlocode tags - what are the general guidelines about cleaning up tag confetti? general tagging

Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-04 Thread Malcolm Herring
On 04/02/2013 18:54, Douglas Fraser wrote: Have design decisions been made? Only the design outline has thus far been discussed. In summary, any feature tagged as a port, harbour, marina or anchorage will have the relevant symbol rendered on the OpenSeaMap Seamark layer. The renderer will

Re: [Tagging] [Imports] RFC - Adding UN LOCODE tags to OSM

2013-02-03 Thread doug . fraser
Followup to my post: I am here at the London OSM Hack Weekend and spoke to someone who explained to me the larger issues and questions about importing / updating metadata like LOCODEs that can't be surveyed - i.e. data where managing the process of keeping it current may be troublesome. I