Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-16 Thread François Lacombe
2015-01-15 21:27 GMT+01:00 Ole Nielsen on-...@xs4all.nl: I'm not sure how these codes could benefit OSM. It's been a long time we need unique codes to identify infrastructure features (or group of features) instead of their own OSM ID (when you delete something and redraw it, the ID has

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-16 Thread François Lacombe
I've already introduced the ref:ERDF:gdo key for French power codification scheme. As suggested, ref:entsoe:eic would stand for European power codification scheme. The power transmission proposal had been updated

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-15 Thread Lukas Sommer
Hello. I think it is a good idea to introduce a new key for this. I would recommand not to use “EU” (or “eu”) within the key. While the fundation of this organization was based on EU laws, it is not directly part of the administration of the EU (not part of the European Commision and also not a

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-15 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2015-01-15 11:08 GMT+01:00 François Lacombe fl.infosrese...@gmail.com: A more complete solution would be ref:eu:entsoe_eic my suggestion is to use the more vocal and less susceptible to confusion form: ref:energy_identification_code=* rather than the cryptic abbreviation. No need to add an

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-15 Thread François Lacombe
Hi Friedrich, Ok for the upper case. I would prefer ref:eu:eic since I'm not sure entsoe isn't used in any other part of the world. Furthermore, the E of EIC stands for ENTSO-E. A more complete solution would be ref:eu:entsoe_eic Cheers *François Lacombe* fl dot infosreseaux At gmail dot

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-15 Thread Ole Nielsen
I'm not sure how these codes could benefit OSM. They seem to be mostly for use in transactions between entities such as TSO's and would have little public interest, even for power grid 'nerds' like me. Further, from where would you get these codes (with an odbl compatible license)? I have

[Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-14 Thread François Lacombe
Hi all, I've just discovered a document published by ENTSO-E which is the European authority for power Transmission System Operators (like RTE in France or TenneT in Germany : https://www.entsoe.eu/about-entso-e/inside-entso-e/member-companies/Pages/default.aspx ) This document summarizes a

Re: [Tagging] Power networks European codification scheme

2015-01-14 Thread Friedrich Volkmann
On 14.01.2015 21:54, François Lacombe wrote: I think it would be great to introduce the key ref:EU:EIC to tag transmission power lines, power plant or transmission power substation with it. These codes seem to be unique all around Europe and they would allow us to sustainably identify a lot