Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Yves
I definitely think it's a matter of permission and opening hours, the polygon where this permission apply is secondary, could it be an admin boundary or reserve of some kind. Let the case where no boundary exists yet in OSM, then map it. Yves Le 21 octobre 2016 15:45:26 GMT+02:00, Kevin

Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Kevin Kenny
On Fri, Oct 21, 2016 at 9:31 AM, Craig Wallace wrote: > > > But that is different from an area is managed primarily to benefit > hunting. eg if they are keeping deer numbers artificially high (feeding > over winter, or breeding), just to allow as many as possible to be shot.

Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Kevin Kenny
That's rather a simplistic view. Hunting reserves exist to protect the land from development so that there will be places where it is possible to hunt and game available to harvest. The important distinction isn't the one between 'hunting reserve' and 'wilderness'; it's the one between 'reserve

Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Craig Wallace
On 2016-10-21 14:07, Greg Troxel wrote: Craig Wallace writes: I think this is wrong. A nature reserve an area to protect wildlife, not to allow it to be shot. A nature reserve is managed for the purposes of conservation. So if an area is primarily for hunting, it is not

Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Greg Troxel
Craig Wallace writes: > I think this is wrong. A nature reserve an area to protect wildlife, > not to allow it to be shot. A nature reserve is managed for the > purposes of conservation. So if an area is primarily for hunting, it > is not a nature reserve. I think you are

Re: [Tagging] Hunting area tagging

2016-10-21 Thread Craig Wallace
On 2016-10-20 16:33, Kevin Kenny wrote: Since nobody else has stepped forward to answer this, as far as I can tell, let me take a whack at it: I think that the best tagging for a hunting reserve that the current renderer knows about is 'leisure=nature_reserve". That's how the state wildlife