Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread stevea
I'm not sure how long it is, but California's Highway 1 along the Big Sur coast (a fairly well known, well loved road) has some equivalently lengthy (or longer) winding road signs I've seen. If anyone cares to Mapillary-sniff, I recall one near Carmel Highlands (near the "pink hotel?") and

Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread Graeme Fitzpatrick
On Thu, 17 Dec 2020 at 11:24, Brian M. Sperlongano wrote: > > > Thanks for the comments! For the specific linked case (winding road for > 74(!) miles), it seems that is already covered in the proposal - > hazard=curves and its sub-tags cover this, and if it truly is 74 > consecutive miles, that

Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread Brian M. Sperlongano
Volker, Thanks for the comments! For the specific linked case (winding road for 74(!) miles), it seems that is already covered in the proposal - hazard=curves and its sub-tags cover this, and if it truly is 74 consecutive miles, that I would think it's just fine to tag 74 miles worth of ways in

Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread stevea
I'm "one more OSM Contributor" volunteering my opinion here. I voted for the hazard proposal as is, although my vote included the note that "this proposal is a solid foundation for the (hazard) syntax of both today and tomorrow." There are such things: OSM has many examples of where we begin

Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread Volker Schmidt
Brian, I am trying to put order in this also in my own mind. I think we should have an approach which is already clearly structured towards two things A the difference between - signposted hazards - unsigned hazards perceived by the mappers B for hazards that may have different degrees of

Re: [Tagging] Rapids (whitewater) on rivers --> Hazards

2020-12-16 Thread Brian M. Sperlongano
As the maintainer of the current hazard proposal - I don't really have strong opinions about signed versus unsigned hazards, though I know others do. However, signed hazards seem to be something that we all agree should be tagged, and this proposal is attempting to approve the collection of