On 02/26/2012 09:16 AM, Mike Valiant wrote:
> Originally there was little mention of any of them tags depicting
> purely legal restrictions. Even access/*=no was "unsuitable or not
> allowed", but later, as it was deemed unverifiable, the "only legal"
> started creeping into all sorts of ta
gate.
>
> Andreas
>
> --
> Date: Sat, 25 Feb 2012 19:48:43 +
> From: grahamjones...@gmail.com
> To: tagging@openstreetmap.org
> Subject: Re: [Tagging] How to tag the width of a gate
>
>
>
> The key "width" can only be applied to a way, not to a node
I agree that maxwidth=any_number should be interpreted as general
restriction without discrimination.
Generally I'd like to see a clearly distinctive tagging of legal (am I
allowed to) vs. physical (will I not get stuck) aspects, but that is
much broader issue than maxwidth.
maxwidth might actually
> Originally there was little mention of any of them tags depicting
> purely legal restrictions. Even access/*=no was "unsuitable or not
> allowed", but later, as it was deemed unverifiable, the "only legal"
> started creeping into all sorts of tags, where it may or may not be
> the common usage
>This was discussed intensely some time ago for maxheight, I suggest
>you read the archives on this. I agree that a physical restriction is
Originally there was little mention of any of them tags depicting
purely legal restrictions. Even access/*=no was "unsuitable or not
allowed", but later, as
Am 26. Februar 2012 13:53 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> IMHO a physical restriction is as important as a legal restriction. If I
> have a wide vehicle and I was using routing software using the OSM database
> it would be useful to be able to put in my vehicle's width and then the
> routing software cou
nstreetmap.org
> Subject: Re: [Tagging] How to tag the width of a gate
>
> Am 26. Februar 2012 13:17 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> > That not what the wiki for maxwidth says: " a width limit for using the way"
> > - no mention of whether it is a legal restriction or not.
Am 26. Februar 2012 13:17 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> That not what the wiki for maxwidth says: " a width limit for using the way"
> - no mention of whether it is a legal restriction or not. And in the
> discussion of maxwidth "width restriction can be physical, or purely legal"
the wiki is not alw
+0100
> From: dieterdre...@gmail.com
> To: tagging@openstreetmap.org
> Subject: Re: [Tagging] How to tag the width of a gate
>
> Am 26. Februar 2012 09:45 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> > If the gate is a node on a way that passes through the gate then I would
> > have thoughtba
On Sun, 26 Feb 2012 20:26:05 Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:
> Am 26. Februar 2012 09:45 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> > If the gate is a node on a way that passes through the gate then I would
> > have thought barrier=gate and maxwidth=xxx on the node that is the
> > gate would be more appropriate. It
Am 26. Februar 2012 09:45 schrieb Mike Valiant :
> If the gate is a node on a way that passes through the gate then I would
> have thought barrier=gate and maxwidth=xxx on the node that is the
> gate would be more appropriate. It defines the maximum size of vehicle
> (person?) that could pass
If the gate is a node on a way that passes through the gate then I would have
thoughtbarrier=gate and maxwidth=xxxon the node that is the gate would
be more appropriate. It defines the maximum size of vehicle (person?) that
could pass through the aperture.
//Mike
@openstreetmap.org
Subject: Re: [Tagging] How to tag the width of a gate
The key "width" can only be applied to a way, not to a node (e.g. a gate).
You could make separate nodes for the two gateposts, with a connecting way to
represent the gate itself, and apply the width tag to that way.
To me t
> The key "width" can only be applied to a way, not to a node (e.g. a gate).
> You could make separate nodes for the two gateposts, with a connecting way
> to represent the gate itself, and apply the width tag to that way.
To me the easiest answer is to use barrier=gate, width=xxx.
I can not s
Volker Schmidt wrote:
> I would like to tag the width (horizontal clearance) of a gate. The
> typical
> application are mountain trails that pass through livestock fences by
> means
> of various types of gates. The trail typically has no width, but the
> gate
> may have it. The key "width" can on
I would like to tag the width (horizontal clearance) of a gate. The typical
application are mountain trails that pass through livestock fences by means
of various types of gates. The trail typically has no width, but the gate
may have it. The key "width" can only be applied to a way, not to a node
16 matches
Mail list logo
